Skip to content
Principles of Accounting | Part 9 of 12

Accounting Profit Can Be Positive While Economic Profit Is Weak

Connect operating earnings with the capital and required return needed to produce them.

A business reports attractive operating profit while tying up substantial capital. Another division has a higher return ratio but rejects growth that would create additional value.

Economic-profit analysis helps connect earnings with the resources and required return behind them.

Define the capital charge

A simplified economic-profit measure deducts a capital charge from after-tax operating profit.

Hypothetical division Value
NOPAT €1,500,000
Invested capital €10,000,000
Capital cost 8%
Capital charge (8% × €10,000,000) €800,000
Economic profit €700,000

The calculation requires consistent definitions, timing and adjustments. EVA is one branded economic-profit approach, not a stock-market return measure.

A positive result under a model is not a guarantee of realized shareholder value.

Align the numerator and capital base

Operating profit should correspond to the activities and resources included in capital.

Cash, leases, development and acquisitions can create definition differences. Explain adjustments and preserve reconciliation.

A hypothetical division can improve its reported measure by transferring resources to a shared function. The group’s economics may remain unchanged.

Avoid rewarding reclassification as value creation.

Compare ratios and absolute value

A return ratio can discourage a manager from accepting a project that earns above the capital cost but below the division’s current average.

Economic profit can make the additional value more visible. It still depends on sound forecasts and appropriate risk assumptions.

Short-term improvement can also be created by deferring investment or capability development.

Use lifecycle evidence rather than treating one annual measure as complete.

Connect the result with operating drivers

Investigate margin, asset use, working capital and necessary reinvestment. Give operating owners measures they can influence.

A capital charge should not become a mysterious central allocation that employees cannot understand.

Review benefits and unintended behavior. The metric should improve resource decisions, not create a new reason to hide commitments.

For the next performance review, explain how the result changes if capital, earnings or assumptions differ.

Value-based management is broader than one formula. It becomes useful when the organization makes better investment, operating and distribution decisions with a transparent view of capital’s opportunity cost.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.