An audit that starts with “we are here for the yearly audit of assembly” ends with a list of missing signatures. The questions were written from a document list, so documents are what the audit finds. Preparation is three hours per audit, and it decides which of the two audits you get.
The example in this series is audit A-16 of the valve plant: the assembly process, stations 1 to 3, early shift, valve family V-200, run by two auditors in September.
Five elements on one page
| Element | What good looks like |
|---|---|
| Objective | Can the line always build the released revision, and is the first piece check used as intended? |
| Scope | Stations 1 to 3, early and late shift, valve family V-200, September to November |
| Criteria | Process description, work instructions, control plan, the customer requirement |
| Inputs | Yield, scrap, two open actions, three complaints, the layout change in July |
| Plan | Nine blocks with times, places, people and records, sent one week before |
The objective is the part people skip. “Audit of assembly” is a title. A sentence that can be answered with yes or no gives the auditor something to aim at.
What to read before the audit
The figures of the last three months with their targets. The last report and the actions it produced, including the ones still open. The complaints, deviations and changes that touched the process. The process description, once. That is also where the questions come from.
The time grid
Planning the audit hour by hour is what keeps the closing meeting from being cut. Audit A-16 ran 285 minutes on site: opening meeting 15 minutes, process walk 45, interview at station 3 and records 90 including a short break, interview with the process owner 45, tracing one order 30, sorting and wording the findings 30, closing meeting 30.
Sixty of those minutes are auditor time without the auditee. Plan it, or it is taken from the end, and the findings are sent two weeks later to people who never heard them.
Questions the process has to answer
A question that can be answered by handing over a document is not a question yet.
| Weak question | Better question |
|---|---|
| Do you have a valid work instruction? | Show me the instruction used for the order running now. |
| Are your gauges calibrated? | Which gauges does this station use, and what happens here if one is overdue? |
| Is the team trained? | Who was released to station 2 last, and what did the release involve? |
| Do you measure your process? | Yield was 96.2 percent in October against a target of 98. What did you do? |
Every question gets a place to look and a sample rule before the audit starts. In A-16 the first question carried “station 3, folder and document list, eight orders”. That sample is what later turned an impression into a finding.
Six questions, not twenty
Six to ten questions for a four-hour audit. Each one needs a place, a sample and the time to follow where it leads. An audit with twenty questions is a questionnaire: every answer is taken as given, because there is no time to look at anything.
Depth is what an internal audit can offer that a document review cannot. It is also the only thing the people in the process will remember a month later.
What the plant changed
Before, the question set was a standing list used in every area. Now it is written for each audit from the process steps, the figures, the complaints, the open actions and the changes since the last audit. Of the ten questions written for the two audits in this example, three led directly to a finding, and the average audit in the second year produced 4.9 findings instead of 7.6, with far fewer of them about paperwork.