Skip to content
Investment and Financing | Part 9 of 12

Required Return Must Match the Claim and Cash Flow

Use risk and funding assumptions consistently when estimating required returns.

A model discounts equity cash flow using a company-wide weighted cost of capital. Another reduces every rate by a tax percentage. Both can produce a precise result from inconsistent logic.

The required return should fit the claim, cash-flow definition and risk being assessed.

Build the equity estimate transparently

CAPM expresses required equity return as a compatible risk-free rate plus beta times an equity market risk premium.

Hypothetical CAPM input Value
Risk-free rate 3.0%
Beta 1.1
Equity market risk premium 5.0%
Required equity return (3.0% + 1.1 × 5.0%) 8.5%

Selecting the inputs requires judgment. Currency, horizon, benchmark and estimation period matter.

The result is neither a guaranteed return nor an observed invoice.

Combine financing costs coherently

A common WACC model weights equity cost and debt cost, including an appropriate treatment of usable interest tax effects.

Source Weight Cost Share
Equity 60% 8.5% 5.1%
Debt, after tax 40% 3.75% 1.5%
WACC 6.6%

The debt line assumes a 5% pre-tax cost and an immediately usable 25% tax benefit. Actual tax limitations and financing changes can require a different model.

Do not reduce a rate again if the relevant tax treatment is already incorporated.

Match the valuation perspective

  • Firm cash flows before financing payments generally require a compatible weighted capital cost.
  • Cash attributable to equity requires an appropriate equity return.

Nominal and real rates also need compatible cash flows, as do currencies.

A rate estimated for the existing business may not fit a different project or instrument.

Specific execution risks may belong in scenarios rather than arbitrary rate additions. Avoid counting the same concern twice.

Review the inputs and consequence

Record sources and dates. Historical textbook figures should illustrate a method, not become permanent corporate parameters.

Show sensitivity and explain whether reasonable alternatives change the conclusion.

A hypothetical long-duration valuation may be highly sensitive to a small rate change, while a short repayment has less exposure.

For the next model, reconcile cash-flow scope, currency, tax and risk before debating decimals.

A useful required-return estimate is reviewable because its assumptions fit together. Precision matters only after that coherence exists.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.