Skip to content
KPI Systems and Balanced Scorecard | Part 7 of 8

Show the Trend, Not the Dot, and Then Decide

Twelve periods with target and reaction limit on every chart, a one-page scorecard, and a review agenda where only figures outside their limit are discussed.

The chart is not decoration. It is the part of the system people actually read, and most of the information lives in its shape rather than in its latest value.

Why a colored dot alone fails

A figure one point below target shows the same color as a figure twenty points below. A figure that has improved for six months and is still short shows the same color as one that collapsed last week. The dot answers where we are, never where we are going. Use a status mark in addition to the trend, never instead of it.

Six rules for a chart

Element Rule
History At least twelve periods on every chart
Target and limit Two lines drawn across the whole period
Scale Fixed over the year, starting where it makes sense
Color One accent for the value, gray for target and limit
Status mark Only in addition to the trend
Owner and update day Printed on the sheet

A moving scale turns normal variation into drama, three bright colors hide the message, and an update day printed on the sheet means an empty chart has an address.

The one-page scorecard

The whole system fits on one page: four blocks for the four views, six small charts each, with trend, target, limit and a status mark. Nobody reads 24 charts in a meeting. The page exists so that the three to five figures outside their limit are found in one minute, and so that everybody sees what else is going on without asking for a report.

Boards at the line

A line board carries five figures, large enough to read from two meters, updated by hand by a named person at a fixed time each day.

Hand drawn is not a weakness: the person who draws the point knows why it moved, and a team that draws its own chart argues with the process rather than with the chart. The Shop Floor Management line covers the daily routine around the board in depth.

The review agenda

Minutes What happens
0 to 5 The scorecard on one page, status against the reaction limit
5 to 30 Per figure outside its limit: the owner gives deviation, cause and proposal in three minutes
30 to 37 Open actions from the last two reviews
37 to 40 Anything that should change in the system itself

Four rules make it work.

Only figures outside their reaction limit are discussed; everything else is visible and silent. The owner of the figure speaks, not the person who made the chart. Three minutes per figure: what moved, why, what I propose, so that the discussion is about the proposal. And no figure leaves without an action with an owner and a date, or a written decision that none is needed.

What changed in the example plant

The review fell from 75 minutes to 40. The 146 figures across 38 pages became 24 on one page. Of eleven deviations shown, four used to be discussed; now all three to five outside the limit are. Actions with an owner and a date rose from one or two per meeting to three to five. About twenty minutes of every old meeting had gone on which number was right, and with one definition per figure that time disappeared.

The minutes are one page: figure, deviation, cause, action, owner, date. They are the input for the next meeting, which is why open actions have their own slot. An action may be re-dated once, with a written reason. The second time it goes to the next level with the question whether it is still the right action.

The same agenda works weekly in an area and daily at a line, with fewer figures and shorter slots. The final part puts the system itself on the agenda.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.