Skip to content
KPI Systems and Balanced Scorecard | Part 1 of 8

What a Key Figure Is For, and How to Spot a Bad One

Every figure should support a named decision. Four faults turn a correct number into a harmful one: wrong incentives, no owner, no decision and no reliable source.

A plant for electric motors and gear units counted the key figures it reported. Across monthly reports, weekly files and boards it found 146. Forty-five had no named owner. Twenty-three had no data source anybody could point at. In the last quarter, 32 of the 146 had triggered a documented action.

That is not a reporting problem. It is an attention problem. Every figure costs the attention of the people who collect it, read it and defend it, and attention is the scarcest resource in a plant.

The two questions

A key figure earns its place by answering two questions in one sentence each.

Which decision does this figure support? And who makes that decision?

If the answer takes a paragraph, the figure is not ready. If there is no answer, the figure is not a key figure. It may still be useful context, in which case it belongs in the report without a target and without a reaction limit, clearly marked as information.

Five purposes cover almost everything a plant needs. A figure can steer, by triggering a decision when it leaves a band. It can warn early, by moving before the result moves. It can prove, by showing whether a change worked. It can hold a level that must not slip. Or it can inform, with no target attached.

Four faults

Bad figures are rarely wrong. They are usually correct, cheap to produce, and they move behavior in a direction nobody wanted.

Wrong incentive. The figure can be improved without improving the plant. Machine utilization of the machining centers, with a target of 90 percent, is the classic case. Planners built long runs to keep the number up, work in process behind machining grew, and lead time grew with it. The figure was retired and replaced by schedule attainment together with the OEE of the bottleneck line.

No owner. When the number moves and three people point at each other, the figure is a rumor. One name, one role. If nobody will take it, the figure goes.

No decision. Nobody can name an action that ever followed. Number of audits performed counted activity while findings stayed open. It was replaced by the share of findings closed within the agreed date.

No reliable source. Two people produce two values for the same month. Twelve variants of scrap, by rate, cost, pieces, line, shift, week and month, made every meeting an argument about which report was right. They became two figures: scrap rate per line and scrap cost per month.

The pair rule

Some figures are worth keeping even though they invite a shortcut. The answer is not to delete them but to publish them with the figure that catches the shortcut, side by side, in the same chart block and for the same period.

Figure that invites a shortcut Published together with
Output per shift First pass yield of the same shift
Machine utilization Lead time or work in process
Conversion cost per unit On-time delivery
Maintenance cost Unplanned downtime rate
Inventory turns Order fill rate

In the example plant, pieces per hour per operator had pushed the first-piece check aside in two of three shifts. It was not deleted. It stayed as a working figure inside the area and was published only next to first pass yield.

Three warning signs

A figure without a reaction limit gets discussed when somebody feels like it. A figure shown as a single number cannot be read, because a value without twelve periods of history has no shape. And a figure that nobody at the place of work has ever used is a figure for the report, not for the plant.

The next part turns the survivors into definition sheets, so that a number means the same thing to everybody who reads it.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.