Skip to content
Master Data and ERP Readiness | Part 3 of 8

Bills of Material and Routings: Check Them Where the Work Happens

Why a bill is correct only when every line is correct, and how wrong standard times hide a work center that is already full.

The bill of material turns a customer order into demand for every part. The routing turns it into load on every work center. Both can only be checked where the work happens: at the assembly bench and at the machine.

The bill against the product

Take the printed bill to the station, build or watch one unit, and compare line by line with the person who assembles it. The gear unit plant checked 60 bills of running products this way. Forty-four were fully correct: a bill of material accuracy of 73 percent.

Main error in the 16 wrong bills Bills
Component missing in the bill 6
Wrong quantity 5
Component replaced, old number still in the bill 3
Wrong unit or conversion 2

Gear unit G-160 shows all three effects at once. The seal kit SK-160 was missing: never planned, never booked, it ran out without warning. The screw M10 x 40 stood at 8 where 12 are used: the stock record grows by 4 per unit built until a count finds it. The breather plug still carried the old part number, so demand was planned for a part nobody buys any more.

Why line accuracy misleads

The 60 bills had 2,280 lines, and 2,231 of them were correct. That is a line accuracy of 97.9 percent, a number that looks like success in any report.

With an average of 38 lines per bill, 49 wrong lines are enough to make 16 bills wrong. Planning does not explode 97.9 percent of a bill. It explodes the whole bill, with the error in it. Measure both numbers, report both, and steer by the bill.

The routing against the machine

A routing counts as correct when the operations are complete, in the real sequence, on the work center where they really run, and when run and setup time are within 10 percent of the measured or confirmed time. Thirty-nine of 60 routings met this rule: 65 percent, the weakest of the four baseline figures.

Thirteen of the 21 wrong routings failed on time alone. The turning cell TC-3 shows what that does.

Item In the routing Measured
Run time per shaft 4.2 minutes 5.6 minutes
Setup time per order 30 minutes 48 minutes
Load per month (5,200 shafts, 40 orders) 384 hours 517 hours
Share of 536 available hours 72 % 97 %

The plan shows a cell at 72 percent with room for more orders. The shop floor runs it at 97 percent with no room for a single disturbance. Every order that planning adds in good faith arrives late, and the delay is blamed on the cell.

Where the real times come from

Time studies give the best data and cost about an hour per operation, so they are worth it on bottleneck work centers. The plant studied 180 operations there and corrected the rest from confirmed times out of production feedback, which are only as good as the feedback discipline. Automatic collection from machine data is covered in the Digital Shop Floor series.

Keeping both correct

Three habits hold the result. Decide which structure planning explodes if engineering and production keep different ones, and name its owner. Handle line material, the seals, screws and labels taken at the line, either in the bill with its quantity or by a two-bin rule outside the planning run, never half of each. And give every assembler one form to report a deviation between bill and product, answered within five days.

Changes with an effective date are a topic of their own, covered in the Engineering Change and Part Approval series.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.