Skip to content
Meetings and Facilitation | Part 4 of 6

Facilitation Tools for Groups: Eight Moves for Working Meetings

Silent collection, round of the table, dot voting, timebox, parking lot and straw poll, plus what to do with dominant speakers, silent participants and open conflict.

Put seven capable people in a room with a question and three of them will answer it. The other four will nod or wait. That is what an unstructured conversation does to any group, and facilitation is the set of small tools that changes it.

All eight tools in this part do the same thing in a different way: they separate collecting from judging.

Eight tools

  • Silent collection. Everyone writes for four minutes before anyone speaks.
  • Round of the table. One sentence from each person in a fixed order, no comments in between.
  • Dot voting. Each person marks three points of the collected list. Twenty points become five in two minutes.
  • Timebox. An item gets its minutes, announced and visible.
  • Parking lot. Points that do not belong go on a sheet with an owner and a date.
  • Straw poll. A show of one to five fingers on readiness to decide.
  • Named question. A question asked to one named person, not to the room.
  • Fact restatement. The leader repeats the question and the figures on the table. A conflict about people becomes a conflict about data.

A discussion item in 15 minutes

In the Monday leadership round of the example plant, the delivery item had 15 minutes: on-time delivery stood at 92.4 percent against a target of 96, and two accounts were at risk. Instead of a status talk and a debate between two people, it now runs like this:

Step Tool Minutes
The question is read out and written on the board Fact restatement 1
Everyone writes the two causes they see Silent collection 3
One sentence each, no comments Round of the table 4
Three marks per person on the list Dot voting 2
Summary, tasks, owners, dates Timebox ends 5

Seven people spoke instead of two.

The person who speaks for half of the round

Change the structure, not the person. Announce the share in advance: two minutes each. Start with silent collection. Then thank, summarize the contribution in one sentence and pass on by name.

The person who never speaks

Silence rarely means there is nothing to say. Ask a named person a narrow question in their own field: “You run the cell. What happens on the late shift when the gauge is occupied?” Use a round of the table, so that speaking is the normal case and not a decision. Never ask “anything to add?”.

Two people in open conflict

Most conflicts in a plant run on two different data sets, a few on two different targets.

  1. Write the question on the board and point at it, not at anyone.
  2. Ask both sides for the facts they are using.
  3. Define the smallest missing fact, give it an owner and a date, and park the question.
  4. If the conflict is about targets and not about facts, hand it to the person who decides. A group cannot vote away a conflict of targets.

How the group decides

There are four modes. One person decides after hearing the room, the default in a plant. A proposal is adopted unless someone objects with a reason. A vote is taken by a rule named beforehand. Or one person decides alone inside stated limits. An idea session and a weighted decision are formats of their own, covered in the Creativity Techniques and Structured Decision Making series.

The next part asks what is left of these tools when half of the group sits on a screen.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.