The basic quality tools work with numbers. At some point in every problem the material changes: the team has opinions, ideas and options, and has to turn them into a decision. Four tools from the family of management and planning tools do that. They need a wall, notes and an hour each.
Affinity diagram: order in many statements
The second problem on powder coating line 2 was inclusions, 480 parts in four weeks, with a peak every Monday. The Monday pattern pointed to dust after the weekend, but the team suspected more than one source. The question went to eight people: why do we have inclusions?
- Everyone writes notes in silence, one statement per note.
- All notes go on the wall. The group sorts them in silence by what belongs together.
- Each group gets a header that says what its notes have in common.
- The discussion is about the groups, not about single notes.
Thirty-two notes became five groups:
| Group | Notes |
|---|---|
| Dust from the hall | 8 |
| Booth and powder recovery | 7 |
| Oven and conveyor | 7 |
| Dirt carried in by parts | 6 |
| People and clothing | 4 |
Tree diagram: from the goal to actions
A tree diagram breaks a goal down, level by level, until every branch ends in something a person can do next week.
The goal for line 2: inclusions below 1 percent of the parts, from a baseline of 2.0 percent. The means, taken from the affinity groups: keep dust out of oven and conveyor, keep the booth clean, keep parts and hall clean. Under each sit the actions: a cleaning routine before the Monday start, the oven entrance on the weekly cleaning plan, a sieve check every shift, filter changes by pressure difference, no cardboard at the hanging station, the gate closed during coating.
Matrix diagram: two lists, one grid
A matrix shows how the items of two lists relate, with a mark for the strength of each relationship: 9 for strong, 3 for medium, 1 for weak, empty for none.
The team set the six named defect types against the six process steps and asked for each cell: is this defect created here? The column sums were 30 for the booth, 21 for the oven, 10 for pretreatment, 9 for packing and 6 each for hanging and drying. Booth and oven are where most defect types are born. Checks, cleaning and attention belong there, not spread evenly along the line.
Prioritization matrix: which option first
By now the team had five options and capacity for two or three. A prioritization matrix ranks options against weighted criteria.
The criteria and weights were fixed first: effect on defects 40 percent, cost 20 percent, time to implement 20 percent, risk to output 20 percent. Then each option was scored from 1 to 5 on each criterion, where 5 is best.
| Option | Score |
|---|---|
| A Raise powder output of the lower guns | 4.6 |
| B Cleaning routine before the Monday start | 4.4 |
| C Clean and rotate hooks every week | 3.8 |
| E Automatic gun control by part type | 3.0 |
| D New filter system for the booth | 2.8 |
What came of it
Options A and B were carried out in weeks 7 and 8, option C was planned, D and E wait for a budget. Twelve weeks after the first check sheet:
| Measure | Baseline | After |
|---|---|---|
| Parts with thin coating in four weeks | 720 | 168 |
| Parts with inclusions in four weeks | 480 | 216 |
| Defect rate | 8.0 % | 4.6 % |
| Rework cost per year in EUR | 345,600 | 216,000 |
Inclusions are at 0.9 percent of the parts. The saving is EUR 129,600 per year. Against it stand EUR 9,600 for more powder on the bottom row, EUR 2,400 for the Monday cleaning and a one-time cost of EUR 8,000, which leaves a net benefit of EUR 117,600 per year.
The next Pareto review already has its subject. Orange peel, untouched so far, is now the largest bar.