Skip to content
Six Sigma | Part 3 of 10

From Customer Words to Measurable Limits

Voice of the customer, critical to quality characteristics and the SIPOC turn vague complaints into a project with clear borders.

“The pump leaks.” That is what the customer says. A machine operator cannot act on it, and a statistician cannot measure it. Somewhere between the complaint and the process, the words have to become numbers.

The critical to quality tree

The translation runs in three steps: what the customer says, what they need, and which characteristic with which limits delivers that need.

Voice of the customer Need CTQ characteristic Limits
“The pump leaks” Tight seal Bore diameter 24.000 mm ± 0.030 mm
“The pump is noisy” Smooth running Bore roundness maximum 0.008 mm
“Delivery is late” Reliable supply First pass yield at least 99 percent

A critical to quality characteristic, CTQ for short, is measurable and has limits. If it has no limits, the project has no definition of a defect.

Where the voice comes from

Customer voices come from complaints, warranty data, audits, specifications, interviews and the assembly line next door. Internal customers count too. The assembly team that receives the housings is a customer of the machining cell.

Be careful with limits that nobody can explain. A tolerance copied from an old drawing may be tighter than needed, or too loose. If the limit drives the whole project, confirm it with design engineering or the customer before you spend months reducing variation against it.

The SIPOC sets the borders

A SIPOC is a one-page map of the project scope: suppliers, inputs, process steps, outputs and customers.

For the bore example:

  • Suppliers: foundry, tool supplier, maintenance, quality.
  • Inputs: cast housing, boring tool, spindle and coolant, gage.
  • Process: clamp, rough bore, finish bore, deburr, measure and release.
  • Outputs: bore diameter, roundness, measurement record.
  • Customers: assembly, the pump customer, quality.

The team then marks where the project starts and ends. Here it starts at clamping and ends at release. Casting and assembly are outside, although their data may still be used.

Why the borders matter

Without agreed borders, every meeting reopens the scope. Someone suggests changing the casting supplier, someone else wants to redesign the seal. Both may be good ideas. Neither belongs in a four-month project on the boring operation.

Write the out of scope items next to the SIPOC and read them aloud at the first tollgate. Ideas outside the scope go to a list for the champion, not into the project.

Keep it to one page

A SIPOC with five to seven process steps is enough. More detail belongs to the process map in Measure and Analyze. The value of the SIPOC lies in a shared picture on the first day, not in completeness.

When the CTQ and the SIPOC are clear, the project has a target that can be measured and a field it can work in. Everything that follows builds on these two pages.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.