Skip to content
Complaint Management | Part 5 of 6

What a Customer Complaint Really Costs

The six cost blocks of a complaint, a worked case at EUR 8,438, and why the credit note is rarely the biggest number on the sheet.

Ask a plant what a complaint costs and you usually get the credit note. In the example plant the credit notes and complaint charges were EUR 33,800 of a total of EUR 307,200. Eleven percent. The rest sat in wages, scrap and capacity, where nobody was looking.

Cost per case is what turns complaint handling from a quality topic into a plant topic. Record it in blocks, for every case, while the case runs.

Six blocks

  • Handling and documentation: hours of the coordinator, the case owner, production and sales at an office rate.
  • Sorting: hours in the plant and at the customer at the shop floor rate, plus travel and any service company invoice.
  • Freight: special transport, express shipments, returns and extra packaging.
  • Scrap and rework: rejected parts at manufacturing cost, rework hours.
  • Replacement parts: the quantity produced again, at manufacturing cost.
  • Credits and charges: credit notes and complaint charges agreed in the delivery terms.

Take the hours from the case while it is open. Hours reconstructed at the end of the year are a guess, and a guess is easy to argue away in a management meeting.

One case

Complaint CPL-2026-012, part 48-220, 120 bad parts found in three lots, 66 parts replaced.

Cost block How it adds up EUR
Handling, documentation and the answer 7 hours at EUR 60 420
Sorting at the customer, two people for a day 16 hours at EUR 60 plus EUR 340 travel 1,300
Sorting of 1,800 parts in our own stock 12 hours at EUR 45 540
Scrap of the 120 rejected parts EUR 18 manufacturing cost each 2,160
Replacement parts, 66 pieces EUR 18 manufacturing cost each 1,188
Special freight for the replacement delivery Next day, one pallet 680
Complaint charge of the customer, settled by credit As agreed in the delivery terms 1,250
Corrective action: new pin, pin gauge, verification Toolmaking and quality 900
Total 2.6 times the average complaint 8,438

Sorting, scrap and freight together are EUR 4,680, more than half the case. The credit the customer actually sees is EUR 1,250.

The year behind the case

Cost block EUR per year Share
Handling, documentation, answers 46,100 15 %
Sorting in the plant and at the customer 86,000 28 %
Freight and special transport 30,700 10 %
Scrap and rework of rejected parts 76,800 25 %
Replacement parts 33,800 11 %
Credits and complaint charges 33,800 11 %
Total of 96 complaints 307,200 100 %

EUR 307,200 is 1.28 percent of the EUR 24.0 million the plant sells. That is the number that works in a management meeting. Cases per month interest the quality department. A share of revenue interests everybody else.

What not to put in the sheet

Lost future sales, damaged reputation and management attention are real, and they cannot be measured per case. Keep them out, so that the figure you report stays one that nobody can argue with, and say in the meeting that the real number is higher. Whether an open case needs a provision in the accounts is a question for your finance function, not a line in this sheet.

What the figure is for

The cost sheet decides where the engineering time goes. Four parts carried 27 of the 96 complaints and a large part of the cost, so they got the gauges and the fixture work. A gauge for EUR 1,200 is easy to approve next to one case of EUR 8,438. And the figure improves as the process gets faster: the cost per complaint fell from EUR 3,200 to EUR 2,850 simply because containment stopped needing special freights and weekend sorting.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.