Skip to content
Maintenance Management | Part 2 of 10

Asset Criticality: Rank Before You Plan

A simple scoring for safety, production, quality and repair effort that ranks every asset A, B or C and decides strategy, priority and spare parts.

A plant with 180 assets cannot give every machine the same attention. Without a ranking, attention follows whoever calls loudest. With a ranking, it follows the damage a failure would cause.

Four criteria, one score

Score each asset from 1 to 5 on four criteria, then weight them:

Criterion Weight Score 1 Score 5
Safety and environment 3 No effect Serious injury or legal breach possible
Production 3 Redundant or buffer above one day Stops the bottleneck or a customer delivery
Quality 2 No effect Scrap or defect at the customer
Repair effort 2 Below 2 hours, parts in stock Above 8 hours or parts above 4 weeks

Criticality score = 3 x safety + 3 x production + 2 x quality + 2 x repair effort. The maximum is 50. Class A from 35 points, B from 20 to 34, C below 20.

Three examples

  • Bottleneck machining center: 3, 5, 4, 5 gives 42 points, class A.
  • Washing machine: 3, 3, 3, 3 gives 30 points, class B.
  • One of three compressors: 1, 1, 1, 3 gives 14 points, class C.

In the example plant, 27 of 180 assets (15 percent) are A, 63 are B and 90 are C. The 27 A assets cause 71 percent of the unplanned downtime.

Score together

Criticality is not a maintenance decision alone. Score in one session per area with the production manager, a maintenance supervisor and someone from quality. When the scores differ, ask one question: what happens in the first hour after this asset fails? The answer usually settles the discussion.

Review the ranking once a year and after every layout change. A machine that becomes the bottleneck after a product change moves to class A, whatever its score was last year.

What the class decides

Class Strategy focus Spare parts Priority in breakdown
A Failure mode analysis, condition based where possible Critical spares on site 1 or 2
B Time based tasks on the main wear parts Wear parts on site 2 or 3
C Run to failure or simple checks From suppliers 3 or 4

The class becomes a field in every work order. When two jobs compete for the same technician, the class decides, not the volume of the phone call.

Common mistakes

  • Everything is A. If more than a quarter of the assets are A, the scoring is too generous. Check the production score: does the asset really stop a delivery?
  • Ranking without consequences. A list that does not change strategies, priorities and spare parts was an exercise, not a decision.
  • Ignoring safety equipment. Cranes, light curtains and fire protection may score low on production but high on safety. The weighting keeps them visible.

The next part shows how to choose a maintenance strategy for the A assets, failure mode by failure mode.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every week.