A flowchart is a drawing of the steps of a process in the order in which they really happen. For quality work it has one main purpose: to show where defects are created, where they are found and how far apart the two are. The check sheet and the Pareto chart tell you what goes wrong. The flowchart tells you where to look.
Five symbols are enough
A rounded box marks the start and the end. A rectangle is an operation: something is done to the part or the document. A diamond is a decision with two exits, yes and no. A D shape is a wait or a buffer. Arrows show the direction, including the way back.
Draw what happens, not what the instruction says
- Fix the start and the end. Everything between them belongs to the chart.
- Walk the process with the people who do it. One note per step.
- Ask after every step what happens when it goes wrong.
- Add the decisions and the ways back. Rework loops are the reason you draw.
- Mark where each top defect is created and where it is found.
Line 2 as a step list
For powder coating line 2 the walk gave ten steps:
- Hang parts on hooks, three rows per hanger.
- Pretreat: degrease, rinse, passivate.
- Dry at 120 °C.
- Coat in the booth with eight guns.
- Cure at 180 °C for 20 minutes.
- Cool down on the conveyor.
- Inspect every part, measure thickness on a sample.
- Decision: part good? Yes goes to step 9, no to step 10.
- Take parts off the hooks and pack.
- Decision: recoat possible? Yes means sand and back to step 1, no means strip or scrap.
Six operations, one wait, one inspection, two decisions, one way back.
Three findings from the walk
Reworked parts were invisible. A sanded part went back to step 1 without any mark. At step 7 it was inspected and counted like a new part. The line therefore coated more than 1,200 parts on some days without anyone knowing how many. The change was simple: a colored tag on the hook for rework and a separate column on the check sheet.
Detection came late. Thin coating is created at step 4, in the booth. It is found at step 7, about 45 minutes later. The line runs at 80 parts per hour, so 60 parts are already coated when the inspector sees the first thin one. The change: a thickness check on the first hanger of each order directly after cooling, before the rest of the order has passed the booth.
Nobody owned the hooks. Hooks covered with cured powder ground the part badly, and badly grounded parts attract less powder. No step in the process checked them. The hook check went onto the start-up sheet.
The distance between cause and detection
For each top defect, count the steps and the minutes between the step where it is created and the step where it is found. Every part made in between is at risk. Shortening that distance is often cheaper and faster than removing the cause, and it pays off for every future cause at the same step as well.
On line 2 the distance for thin coating was three steps and 45 minutes. After the change it is one hanger.
In the office
For processes that cross departments, a chart with lanes shows one more thing: the handovers. An order that goes from sales to engineering to planning and back to sales has three places where information is lost and where it waits. In office processes most defects are created at handovers, and most of the lead time is waiting between lanes. The decision diamonds deserve the same attention as on the shop floor. Each “no” exit is a loop, and each loop is rework that usually nobody counts.