Skip to content
Structured Decision Making | Part 1 of 6

Frame the Decision: One Question, One Decider, One Date

How to turn a topic into a decision: the question, the trigger, the deadline, how reversible it is, and who decides and who is only heard.

A plant for welded steel assemblies buys 420,000 laser-cut blanks per year from two suppliers, for EUR 1,726,000. Within four weeks, both suppliers write that they will not add more than 5 percent of volume. For four months the plant talks about “the laser topic”. Two options circulate, keep buying or buy a large cell, EUR 48,000 goes into a layout study, and nothing is decided. Nobody is to blame for this. The matter was never framed as a decision.

A topic is not a decision

A topic can be discussed forever. A decision has one question with one choice, and a date. The difference shows in the wording.

  • Topic: “Our laser suppliers are a problem.”
  • Decision: “How do we cover the demand for laser-cut blanks from the coming year on?”

The second sentence can be answered. It also leaves the solution open.

Five lines before the first meeting

The frame fits on half a page.

  • Question. One sentence, one choice.
  • Trigger. What makes this a decision now. Here: two written refusals of additional volume.
  • Needed by. A date with a reason. A laser cell needs nine months from order to first part, so the decision is needed by the end of the quarter.
  • Cost of deciding late. Each month of delay moves the first part by a month and buys volume at a surcharge of about 8 percent.
  • Class. How hard the decision is to undo.

The fourth line is the one most often missing. Without it, waiting looks free.

How reversible is it

Not every choice deserves the same effort. Three classes are enough.

  • Class 1: can be undone in three months for less than EUR 10,000. Decide in the meeting, three lines in a register.
  • Class 2: undoing costs up to EUR 100,000 or three months. One page with three options and criteria.
  • Class 3: investment above EUR 250,000, long contracts, positions. A full sheet with weights, cases and a record.

The laser decision is class 3.

Who decides and who is heard

Most slow decisions are not difficult. They are unowned. Four roles, written once per decision, remove the loop.

  • Decides: one named person. In the plant, the plant manager. A group can advise, but one person signs. Two deciders is none.
  • Must be heard: production, quality, purchasing, controlling and the employee representatives. Each owes a written statement by a date. Being heard means the statement was read. It does not mean a veto.
  • Supplies facts: controlling, purchasing, maintenance and planning. They deliver numbers with a source and a date, not opinions.
  • Informed: the welding supervisors and both suppliers. They receive the decision note within five working days.

The dates run backward from the deadline: facts by day 40, statements by day 50, decision by day 60.

Thresholds change the options

Every organization has limits on who may decide what. Write them down before the options are compared, because they are part of the options. In the plant, the plant manager may decide investments up to EUR 500,000. Anything above goes to an investment committee that meets once per quarter. One of the later options costs EUR 740,000. The committee would have added up to three months to a nine-month delivery time. That is a property of the option and belongs in its evaluation.

What the frame changed

With the frame written, the second attempt took eight weeks instead of four months. It produced five options instead of two and ended with a signed note of one page. The EUR 48,000 of the first attempt appeared in none of the options, because money already spent cannot be recovered by any of them.

The frame says what is to be decided and by whom. It does not yet say what a good answer looks like. That is the job of the criteria in the next part.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.