Skip to content
Structured Decision Making | Part 2 of 6

Must and Want Criteria: What a Good Answer Looks Like

How to separate must criteria from want criteria, write them so that evidence can settle them, and find the weights with a paired comparison.

Ask a management team for its decision criteria after it has seen the options, and you get a list that fits the favorite. Criteria written after the options are a justification. Criteria written before are a decision. The plant with the laser blank question therefore closed the cost estimates in a folder and wrote its criteria first.

A criterion must be able to separate two options

Many criteria on a first list cannot do that.

  • “Future proof.” Every option scores well and no evidence settles it. Better: capacity covers the volume plus 15 percent at two shifts.
  • “Low risk.” Mixes volume risk, technical risk and supplier risk. Better: cost per blank at 80 percent of volume.

The test is simple: can two people with the same facts arrive at the same score? If not, the criterion measures a preference.

Must and want

A must excludes an option completely. It has no weight and no score, only a yes or a no that evidence can answer. A want separates the options that remain. It is weighted and scored from 0 to 10 against a written definition.

The plant wrote four musts:

  • M1: capacity for 420,000 blanks plus 15 percent, secured in writing.
  • M2: fits into the 1,150 square meters of free hall space, with a clear height of 9.5 meters.
  • M3: thick plate up to 20 millimeters available, cut in house or purchased.
  • M4: runs on the existing two-shift model, without a new shift agreement.

Three to five musts are a good number. Too many leave no options at all. The test for each: would you reject the otherwise best option because of this one sentence? If the honest answer is no, it is a want with a high weight.

Weights from a paired comparison

Asking a group for percentages gives numbers that add up to 140. Asking for one comparison at a time works better. Every criterion is compared with every other: 2 points if the first matters more, 1 point each if they are equal, 0 if the second matters more. Six criteria give 15 pairs and 30 points. The weight of a criterion is its points divided by 30, rounded to whole percent.

Want criterion Points Weight
Total cost over five years 9 30 %
Delivery reliability and lead time 7 23 %
Flexibility for new parts and small batches 5 17 %
Capital tied up and risk if volume falls 4 13 %
Quality and process control 3 10 %
Implementation effort and people 2 7 %

Each participant fills the matrix alone. Then the group reconciles only the pairs where the answers differ. In the plant, that was mainly one pair: cost against delivery reliability. After 20 minutes the group settled on equal, which is why cost has 9 points and not 10. A seventh criterion on the first list found no defender in any comparison and was dropped.

Anchors for every want

A weight is useless if a 7 means something different to each person. So every want gets a measurable definition. For delivery reliability: working days from call-off to blanks at the welding cell, and the share of late deliveries. For capital and volume risk: investment plus stock, and the cost per blank at 80 percent of volume.

The same idea of weighting appears in value analysis, where it ranks the functions of a product. Here it ranks what the organization wants from a decision.

Three rules for the session

  • Weights are agreed before any option is scored. Afterward they are a way to make the favorite win.
  • No prices in the room until the weights are fixed. The first number spoken would set the frame.

With four musts and six weighted wants, the plant knew what a good answer would look like. It did not yet have enough answers to choose from. The next part is about finding them.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.