Every plant knows the request: take ten percent out of this product. What follows is a round of thinner walls, cheaper suppliers and warranty claims nine months later. Value analysis starts somewhere else. Before a single idea is allowed in the room, two things have to be on the table: the right product, and an honest statement of what it costs.
Pick the product by numbers, not by volume of complaint
A value study occupies six to eight people for several days. Spend those days where the money is and where the design can still move. Four criteria decide.
Cost volume is the first: annual quantity times unit cost. A product with a thin margin but a small volume cannot repay the effort. Margin gap is the second: how far the product is from the margin the company needs, today and after the next price round. Remaining life is the third, because a change that pays back in nine months is worthless on a product that will be discontinued in six. Design freedom is the fourth: a catalog product with your own specification can be changed by your own decision, a customer-approved part cannot.
The worked example in this series is a coolant pump, the CP 40, from a maker of circulation pumps for machine tools. It is one of five families, and the portfolio table makes the choice easy.
| Product | Margin | Units per year | Cost volume EUR |
|---|---|---|---|
| CP 25 | 21.7 % | 9,000 | 1,332,000 |
| CP 40 | 16.0 % | 12,000 | 2,640,000 |
| CP 65 | 21.2 % | 3,500 | 1,435,000 |
| IP 20 | 15.2 % | 6,000 | 570,000 |
The IP 20 has the worst margin, but it carries 8 percent of the cost volume. The CP 40 carries 39 percent and its margin is already short. It will be sold for at least six more years. That is the object.
The target comes from the market
A target cost is not last year’s cost minus a percentage. It is derived from the price the product will have to carry.
The sales team expects EUR 245.00 in twelve months, taken from three lost quotations and two key account negotiations. Today the pump sells for EUR 262.00. The product line needs a margin of 20 percent. Target cost = 245.00 x (1 - 0.20) = EUR 196.00. The pump costs EUR 220.00 today, so the gap is EUR 24.00 per unit, 10.9 percent, or EUR 288,000 per year.
Written that way, the target has a number, a date and an owner. “Reduce cost” is a wish. “EUR 196.00 in the standard cost by month nine” is something a team can finish.
The cost statement is the baseline
The last step before the method begins is a table with one row per component, split into material, manufacturing and overhead, in EUR per unit. Ten to fifteen rows are enough. Group the small parts, and give assembly, testing, coating and packaging rows of their own: they carry cost and they serve functions, even though they are not parts.
For the CP 40 the total is EUR 220.00: material 124.00, manufacturing 52.00, overhead 44.00 at 25 percent on direct cost. The motor with its coupling is the largest single row at EUR 60.00, and the three largest components together carry 56 percent of the cost.
Two rules make the table usable. The total must equal the standard cost to the cent, and controlling has to sign it. Every saving found in the next weeks will be measured against this line, and a baseline that nobody owns produces savings nobody believes. How the calculation itself is built, and how overhead rates are set, belongs to cost accounting and is taken as given here.
With the object chosen, the target set and the cost stated, the team can finally ask the question that makes the difference: what does this product actually do?