Nobody decides to scrap good parts. It happens when a change arrives on the shop floor before anyone has asked what it touches. Purchasing hears about it late, so old parts keep arriving. Planning does not know the date, so the reorder point of the old part triggers one more order. The work instruction follows three weeks later.
A pump plant with 220 employees counted the result for one year: 96 engineering changes closed, 32 of them introduced before evaluation and decision, and EUR 86,000 of old parts written off. EUR 61,000 of that came from the 32 rush changes. A rush change cost EUR 1,906 in old parts on average, an evaluated change EUR 391.
What counts as a change
A change is every planned change to something that was released: a drawing, a bill of material, a specification, a process step, a tool, a program, a material or a supplier. If it was released, it changes only through a numbered request.
A deviation is something else. It permits a difference from the drawing for a limited quantity or time and ends by itself.
Three classes
Not every change needs the same path. The class decides how much process is required.
- Class A: form, fit, function, safety or the customer interface is affected. Full evaluation, board, customer notification, full part approval. 22 of the 96.
- Class B: process, tool, material source or supplier changes, the drawing features stay. Full evaluation, board, approval for what the change can touch. 38 of the 96.
- Class C: documents only. Engineering and quality sign, the board is informed. 36 of the 96.
A corrected drawing note must not wait for a meeting. In the plant, class C changes took 30 working days on average. That is the first place to look.
The request
The request is one page that anyone may write. It describes the problem and the proposal, not the finished solution: number, reason, current state with a figure, proposed change, affected parts and products, expected benefit.
The example that runs through this series is request EC-118. Pump family P-300 leaks at the cover joint. 0.8 percent of delivered pumps come back, 240 complaints per year at EUR 310 each. The proposal: replace the flat gasket by an O-ring in a groove in the housing. The plant builds 125 pumps per day.
Six questions
Before the decision, six departments answer one question each in writing, within five working days.
| Dimension | Answer for EC-118 |
|---|---|
| Cost | EUR 25,250 once, EUR 68,100 benefit per year |
| Date | 40 working days after the decision |
| Stock | 5,900 covers and 6,700 gaskets in stock and on order |
| Tools | Die insert at the supplier, groove tool, fixture jaw |
| Documents | 14 documents and 8 master data records |
| Customer | Two customers notified, one must approve |
The one-time cost includes the die insert for the new cover at EUR 9,800, engineering and tests, documents and EUR 2,310 for old parts. The yearly benefit is 210 fewer complaints at EUR 310 and EUR 0.10 less per pump. Payback: 25,250 / 68,100 x 12 = 4.4 months.
An answer may be “not affected”. But it must be written by the department that would be affected, not assumed by the requester.
New number or new revision
One more question belongs to the evaluation. Can old and new parts be mixed in stock and in assembly without any effect? If yes, the part keeps its number and gets a new revision. If no, it gets a new number and the old one stays alive for service.
In EC-118 the new cover has no gasket face and fits only the housing with the groove. Housing, cover and seal get new numbers. The pump keeps its number, because its connections and its performance stay the same for the customer.
A request with all six answers is ready for the decision. A request with an open dimension is not, however urgent it feels.