A changed part with an unchanged work instruction is a defect waiting for a shift. Most plants update the drawing reliably. What follows the drawing is where changes stay half finished.
The pump plant audited 20 closed changes. In 9 of them, at least one record had not been updated:
| Finding | Changes |
|---|---|
| Old work instruction still at the station | 4 |
| Inspection plan not updated | 3 |
| Reorder parameter of the old part still active | 2 |
Each of these changes was marked as closed in the register.
One list per change
The remedy is one list per change that names every affected document and every affected master data record, with an owner and a due date per line. The list is created with the evaluation.
For change EC-118, the O-ring groove on pump P-300, the list has 22 lines: 14 documents and 8 master data records.
The documents
- Drawings: housing H-41, cover C-13 and the pump assembly. Three documents.
- Bill of material of P-300 with the new housing, cover and O-ring.
- Routing of the housing with the groove operation, 12 seconds more.
- Work instructions for housing machining, pump assembly and leak test. Three documents.
- Control plan and process FMEA with the groove and the O-ring assembly.
- Inspection plans for incoming inspection of the cover and for the groove check in process.
- Spare parts list and customer documentation, so that service knows which seal fits which pump.
How FMEA and control plan are built is covered in the FMEA and Control Plan series.
The master data
Master data causes more damage than a drawing when it is wrong, because the system acts on it without asking.
- Item numbers for the new housing, cover and O-ring, created after the decision with all views.
- Planning parameters of the old cover and the old gasket, set to run-out on the day of the decision. No automatic reorder.
- Purchasing records with price and supplier for the new parts, before the first order.
- Validity of the new bill of material and routing, switched on the effective date.
- Standard cost of the pump, EUR 0.10 lower.
- Service stock: 500 old gaskets moved to the spare parts location.
Note the different dates. The planning parameters change on the day of the decision, 40 working days before the build changes. The bill of material switches exactly on the effective date. A list without dates per line cannot show this.
Old versions leave the station
A new work instruction at the station does not help while the old one hangs beside it. On the effective date, old versions are removed from the stations, and the supervisor signs the removal on the list.
No closure with an open line
The rule that holds everything together: a change is closed only when every affected line is done.
In the plant, the time from the effective date to the closure was 15 working days on average. With the list, the target is 5 days. EC-118 was closed on day 53 after the request, five working days after the effective date. The last two lines were the customer documentation and the standard cost.
Check by sample
A list can be ticked without the work being done. The change coordinator therefore checks three closed changes per month where the change lives: at the station, in the system and in the warehouse.
The share of audited changes without a finding is a key figure of the process. In the plant it started at 55 percent. The target is 95 percent.