Skip to content
Engineering Change and Part Approval | Part 3 of 6

Effectivity: Cut-In Date, Run-Out and Residual Stock in EUR

How to set the effective date of a change, count old parts on the day of the decision and compare run-out options in EUR.

Every approved change needs one sentence that says from when the new state applies. This sentence, the effectivity rule, decides what happens to the old parts. Without it, everything ordered until the new parts arrive is paid for and written off.

Three rules

  • Fixed date. From this day or serial number, only the new state is built. Used for quality, safety or customer reasons.
  • Run-out. The old part is used up, and the change takes effect with the last old part. Used for cost reductions without risk in the old state.
  • Immediate. Stop now, old parts are blocked. Used for safety or legal reasons.

Count on the day of the decision

On the day the board decides, logistics counts the stock and purchasing lists the open orders and asks the supplier what can still be reduced.

For change EC-118, the O-ring groove on pump P-300, the earliest effective date is 40 working days after the decision: 25 for the die insert of the new cover, 15 for samples and approval. At 125 pumps per day the plant still needs 5,000 sets of old parts.

Old part Available Needed Left over EUR
Cover C-12 5,900 5,000 900 5,760
Gasket G-7 6,700 5,000 1,700 1,360

Available means stock plus open orders: 2,300 covers in stock and 3,600 on order. A cover costs EUR 6.40, a gasket EUR 0.80. Without any action, EUR 7,120 of old parts are left on the effective date.

Three options in EUR

The board compared three ways to introduce the change.

Option 1: fixed date, no action. Effective on day 48 after the request. 900 covers and 1,700 gaskets are left over. Cost: EUR 7,120.

Option 2: run out the covers. The 5,900 covers last 47 working days, so the change takes effect on day 55. Only 25 covers and 825 gaskets remain, EUR 820. But seven more days of the old design mean 875 more pumps with a complaint rate of 0.8 percent: 7 complaints at EUR 310, EUR 2,170. Cost: EUR 2,990.

Option 3: fixed date, last order reduced. Effective on day 48. The supplier accepts a reduction of the last order by 900 covers for a fee of EUR 1.50 per piece, EUR 1,350. Of the 1,700 gaskets, 500 go to service stock for pumps of the old design in the field and 1,200 are scrapped, EUR 960. Cost: EUR 2,310.

The board chose option 3. It costs EUR 4,810 less than doing nothing and brings the better seal seven working days earlier than the run-out.

What each leftover part gets

Every old part needs a decision before the effective date:

  • Use up when the old state has no risk.
  • Rework when the old part can be brought to the new state for less than its value. The housings of P-300 get the groove for EUR 4.50 instead of being scrapped at EUR 38.00.
  • Keep for service when products in the field need the part.
  • Reduce the order while the supplier has not yet produced.
  • Scrap when nothing else applies, booked to the change.

Two dates, not one

A change has two dates. On the day of the decision, orders and planning parameters of the old parts change: no automatic reorder, no production order beyond the need. On the effective date, the build changes.

Plants that know only the second date pay for everything ordered between the two. Option 3 worked only because purchasing called the supplier on the day of the decision.

Record the break

On the evening before the effective date, old covers and gaskets leave the assembly stations and are counted. The date and the first serial number of the new state go into the register. Leftover old parts get a blocked stock status on the same day, so that no order can pick them.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.