Skip to content
Engineering Change and Part Approval | Part 5 of 6

Initial Samples and Part Approval, Also for Process and Supplier Changes

What a part approval shows, how to grade the scope of evidence and which process and supplier changes need one even when the drawing stays the same.

A released drawing says what the part should be. It does not say that the supplier’s modified tool makes it. Part approval closes this gap: before a changed part is delivered in series, measured samples from the real process show that it meets every requirement.

What an approval shows

  • Identity: part number, revision, change number, supplier, site, tool and cavity. The samples come from the series tool and the series process.
  • Dimensions: every characteristic the change can have touched, measured on an agreed number of parts.
  • Material and function: certificates and the tests the specification requires.
  • Process evidence: updated FMEA and control plan, capability of special characteristics.
  • Decision: approved, approved with conditions or rejected, with signature and date. A reference sample is kept.

In automotive supply chains, two reference manuals describe this: the production part approval process of AIAG and the production process and product approval of VDA volume 2. Other industries use a first article inspection. All of them grade how much evidence the supplier submits and how much it only keeps on file. Use the valid editions and your customer requirements.

Grade the scope

The pump plant wrote its own rule with three scopes:

  • Basic: signed declaration, data sheet, five parts measured for the main characteristics. For standard parts and documentation changes.
  • Extended: full measurement of the affected characteristics and material evidence. For process changes without a new tool.
  • Full: complete measurement of five parts, material, function, capability and process evidence. For class A changes, new or modified tools and new sites.

The approval plan of EC-118

Change EC-118 replaces a flat gasket by an O-ring on pump P-300. The plan has one line per part and is written with the evaluation, not when the samples arrive.

Part Scope Result
Cover C-13 Full Rejected on day 36, approved on day 45
Housing H-41 Full, internal Groove in tolerance, capability 1.74
O-ring R-22 Basic Declaration and 5 rings measured
Pump P-300 Function No leak in 500 hours on 6 pumps

The cover is the instructive case. Five parts from the modified die were measured for all 28 characteristics. 138 of 140 values were in tolerance. The chamfer at the sealing face was too large on two parts, a feature the change had not meant to touch. The supplier corrected the insert, new samples were in tolerance, and the cover was approved three days before the effective date.

Two lessons: measure the whole part when a tool was modified, and plan reserve between samples and the effective date.

When the drawing stays the same

Many changes never appear on a drawing. A die is replaced, production moves to a second machine, a sub-supplier changes. The part number stays, the part changes anyway. The plant’s rule lists what must be announced before introduction:

  • A new, modified or additional tool, die, mold or cavity.
  • Production moved to another site, line or machine type.
  • A new sub-supplier or material source.
  • A process step added, removed, moved or outsourced.
  • A restart after more than twelve months without production.

In one year the plant recorded 22 supplier and process changes. 17 were announced. 5 were found afterward, at incoming inspection or in the line, and cost EUR 19,300 in sorting, scrap and line stops. The largest case: a casting supplier moved the housing to a second machine without notice. 180 housings failed the leak test, EUR 6,840.

Rules for suppliers

  • Announcement in writing at least twelve weeks before the planned introduction.
  • No delivery of changed parts before the written approval.
  • An unannounced change is treated as a complaint with cost recovery.

The same list applies to the plant’s own production. Toward its customers, the plant is the supplier, and a groove machined on a different machine is a process change like any other. How suppliers are selected and developed is the subject of the Supplier Management series.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.