Skip to content
FMEA and Control Plan | Part 5 of 6

Action Priority and Risk Reduction

Why the action priority replaced the risk priority number, how a simple priority logic works and which actions really lower the risk.

Three ratings per cause are not yet a decision. For decades the decision came from the risk priority number, the product of severity, occurrence and detection. The joint FMEA handbook of the American and German automotive associations dropped it in 2019 and introduced the action priority. The reason shows up in almost any FMEA.

What is wrong with multiplying

In the FMEA of the hose assembly cell H2, three rows make the point:

Failure S O D RPN
Elbow angle wrong, hose twisted when installed 6 6 6 216
Crimp position offset, fitting can pull off 9 4 6 216
Crimp diameter too small, hose fails early 9 3 6 162

The first two rows score the same, although one is a nuisance and the other can hurt someone. The third, with a severity of 9, falls below a common limit of 200 and is never discussed.

The product treats the three ratings as equal, and they are not. The ratings are ranks, and a 6 is not twice a 3. And a limit invites games: one rating goes down by a point and the action disappears.

Severity first

The action priority looks at severity first, then occurrence, then detection, and gives one of three levels: high, medium or low. Many customers prescribe the table of the handbook. Where nobody does, a plant can use a simplified logic of its own, written down and marked as a working aid:

Step 1. Read the base priority from severity and occurrence.

Occurrence 1 2 to 3 4 to 6 7 to 10
Severity 9 to 10 Low Medium High High
Severity 7 to 8 Low Medium Medium High
Severity 4 to 6 Low Low Medium Medium
Severity 1 to 3 Low Low Low Low

Step 2. Adjust for detection. A weak check, rated 7 to 10, raises the priority by one level, unless occurrence is 1 or severity is 3 or lower. A strong check, rated 1 to 3, lowers medium to low. It never lowers high.

A high priority should go away because the cause became rarer, not because an inspection was added. Customer and handbook requirements take precedence over such a simplified logic.

What the levels demand

High means an action, or a written reason signed by management. Medium means an action or a written reason. Low leaves the action optional.

In cell H2 the 24 causes split into 8 high, 9 medium and 7 low. Five of the eight high rows sit at crimping and testing.

Actions that lower the risk

The order of actions follows the order of the ratings:

  1. Remove the cause. A reel barcode releases the saw. A wrong hose type cannot be cut.
  2. Make the cause rare. The order barcode selects the crimp program instead of the operator.
  3. Detect automatically. A pressure sensor decides pass or fail and the bench holds failed parts.
  4. Detect with a gauge. A go and no-go gauge for the crimp diameter, on the first part and every 50th.

Training supports these actions. Alone it changes almost nothing.

Only proof changes a rating

A decided action changes no rating. The new numbers are entered when the effect is shown: the wrong reel is mounted and the saw stays locked.

Cell H2 decided 12 actions for EUR 26,400. After all were verified, no high priority was left: 12 rows were medium and 12 low.

Three high rows went to low, because the cause was excluded or the check became automatic. Five went to medium: the cause is rare now, but a person still does the check. The priority tells you where to act. It is not a certificate that the risk is gone.

Keeping the new controls alive every day is the job of the control plan, the subject of the last part.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.