An FMEA that ends in a folder has changed nothing. Its controls have to reach the station and stay there. The document that carries them is the control plan.
What a control plan says
A control plan lists every characteristic that is checked in the process, one line each:
- the process step and the characteristic, product or process,
- the requirement, as a value with tolerance or a limit sample,
- a mark for special characteristics,
- the control method: gauge, sensor, fixture, look with limit sample,
- sample size and frequency,
- the reaction plan.
Every column has a source in the FMEA. Characteristic and requirement come from the function analysis, the method is the prevention or detection control, and the frequency follows from occurrence and severity.
The lines that matter most
The control plan of the hose assembly cell H2 has 16 lines. Seven of them protect a failure with a severity of 9 or 10 and are marked as special characteristics:
| Characteristic | Method | Frequency |
|---|---|---|
| Hose type matches the order | Reel barcode releases the saw | Every reel |
| Insertion depth | Marking fixture, mark at the ferrule edge | Every part |
| Crimp program matches the order | Order barcode selects the program | Every job |
| Crimp diameter 24.6 mm plus or minus 0.15 | Go and no-go gauge, run chart | First and every 50th part |
| Crimp position | Sensor at the stop releases the stroke | Every part |
| Proof pressure 420 bar for 10 seconds | Fixed program with sensor, master sample | Every part |
| Tested mark on the ferrule | Automatic marker | Every part |
The same mark appears in the FMEA, the control plan and the work instruction.
The reaction plan
A check without a reaction is a measurement for the file. For each line, the reaction plan answers four questions in the words the operator uses. For a crimp diameter outside 24.45 to 24.75 mm:
- What do I do with this part? Red bin, locked.
- What about the parts before it? Lock all parts since the last good check, at most 50, and gauge each one.
- What about the process? Stop the crimper. No adjustment by the operator.
- Whom do I call, and who restarts? Setter and cell leader. Restart after two good parts, with an entry on the run chart.
Most plans forget the second question. A check on every 50th part means that up to 50 parts are suspect when it fails.
Check the link both ways
Forward: every control named in the FMEA is a line in the control plan. In cell H2, 23 of the 24 rows point to a line.
Backward: every control plan line protects at least one FMEA row. A line without a row is a check nobody can explain.
Keeping both alive
Step 7 of the method reports the result to management: scope, causes, priorities before and after, actions and cost. Then the life of the document begins. Four events open it again:
- a customer complaint or a new internal failure,
- a change of process, tool or material, before it goes live,
- an audit finding at one of the controls,
- twelve months without a review.
Each review leaves a line in the change history: date, trigger, rows touched and what changed in both documents.
One figure shows how good the analysis was: how many complaints and new failures were already a row in the FMEA? In six months, cell H2 logged six. Five were already rows. The sixth, a thread damaged in a bulk bin, became a new one.
What it paid
After six months, cell H2 had made 46,000 assemblies with 2 complaints and a reject rate of 0.20 percent. The sister cell had 12 complaints and 0.50 percent in a year.
Actions and team hours cost EUR 31,200. Failure cost fell from EUR 53,500 per year at the old level to EUR 18,600, a difference of EUR 34,900.
The payback is 10.7 months. It does not count the hose that never came off.