Skip to content
Hoshin Kanri | Part 4 of 8

Catchball: Targets Become Commitments

How objectives are negotiated between levels in Hoshin Kanri, with capacity, conditions and a written agreement.

A target that arrives by email in January belongs to the sender. A target that a team has questioned, adjusted and agreed to belongs to the team. Catchball is the process that makes the difference.

The ball goes back and forth

The leadership team throws an objective to the next level: “Lead time 13 days by December through pull between assembly and pre-assembly.” The receiving managers do not simply accept it. They answer three questions:

  1. What can we contribute, and by when?
  2. What do we need: people, money, decisions, support from other areas?
  3. What will we stop or slow down to make room?

The answer goes back up. The leadership team adjusts the objective, the resources or the other priorities. After two or three rounds the level has a commitment it believes in.

Capacity is part of the conversation

The most common failure of strategy deployment is the assumption of free capacity. A team leader with a full daily workload receives three improvement projects and no relief.

Make capacity visible in catchball. A simple table helps: available improvement hours per person per month, after daily management, absences and training, against the hours the proposed priorities need. If the demand is 150 percent of the capacity, something has to give, and it is better to decide that in January than to discover it in July.

Horizontal catchball

Breakthrough objectives cross departments. Pull between assembly and pre-assembly needs logistics, production planning and maintenance. Catchball therefore also runs sideways: the owning department agrees with the supporting departments what each delivers and when.

Write these agreements down. “Maintenance supports two changeover workshops in March and May with one technician each” is a commitment. “Maintenance supports” is not.

Conditions and limits

A commitment can come with conditions: “Lead time 13 days, provided the new supermarket area is released by the end of February.” Conditions are not excuses. They become milestones in the plan and items for the monthly review.

How long it takes

For a plant with three levels, catchball takes four to six weeks. It often starts in November for the following year. That feels slow compared to sending targets by email. It is fast compared to a year of misunderstanding.

The output

At the end, every priority has an owner, a plan with milestones, measures with monthly targets, and the agreed support from other areas. The next part shows how these measures are tracked month by month with a bowling chart.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.