Skip to content
Hoshin Kanri | Part 6 of 8

The Monthly Hoshin Review: Red Is Good News

A monthly review rhythm that turns red values into countermeasures, with a fixed agenda, A3 thinking and clear escalation.

In many reviews a red value starts a defense. The owner explains why the month was special, the meeting moves on, and next month the same cell is red again.

In a Hoshin review a red value is good news. It shows a gap early enough to act.

A fixed agenda

The monthly review of one breakthrough objective takes 30 to 45 minutes and follows the same order every time:

  1. Lagging result: where is the objective against the plan?
  2. Leading measures: which bowling chart cells are red?
  3. For each red cell: cause, countermeasure, owner, date.
  4. Countermeasures from last month: done, effective?
  5. Help needed: decisions, resources, support from other areas.

The owner presents. The leadership team asks questions. Decisions are written down in the meeting.

From red to countermeasure

A red cell needs an analysis, not an apology. A short A3 or a one-page countermeasure sheet is enough:

  • the gap in numbers,
  • the cause, checked at the place where the work happens,
  • the countermeasure and its expected effect,
  • owner and date.

Example: part numbers in pull are 38 instead of 45 in March. Cause: Kanban cards for seven part numbers were printed but the supplier deliveries were still planned by forecast. Countermeasure: switch the seven part numbers to call-offs by Kanban signal, purchasing, by 15 April.

Questions that help

Good review questions are short and open: What did you see yourself? What is the cause? What will you try? What do you need from us? Questions that look for a culprit end the honesty of the reporting within two months.

Escalation

If a countermeasure does not work in two consecutive months, or the objective as a whole falls behind by more than an agreed margin, the topic moves to the leadership team as a decision: more resources, a changed plan, or a conscious reduction of the target. All three are legitimate. Silence is not.

Rhythm across levels

Reviews run as a cascade. Team level in the first week of the month, department level in the second, leadership level in the third. Each level brings the red cells and decisions it could not solve.

Keep the rhythm even in busy months. The month the review is skipped is usually the month the plan starts to slip.

What leaders learn

After six months the reviews show patterns: which areas always lack capacity, which kinds of countermeasures work, which measures were badly chosen. This is the material for the annual reflection, the topic of the last part.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.