A plant that makes hydraulic valve blocks buys 480 part numbers from 64 suppliers and takes in 24 goods receipts a day. For years the rule was simple: check what arrives. Ninety of the 120 receipts a week were inspected, each one for about 22 minutes, which came to 1,584 hours and EUR 71,280 a year.
It did not work. Thirty-eight supplier defects a year still reached assembly, and six of them reached the customer. A socket screw and a ground valve spool got the same five dimensions and the same twenty minutes, while lots queued three days for a check that took twenty minutes.
The problem was never the effort. It was that the effort was spread evenly over parts with very different risk.
Three questions per part
A scope is a decision about attention. Three questions give it a basis you can defend in an audit, and each one is answered by a different person.
Effect. What happens if a defective part passes unnoticed? Score 4 if function or safety fails at the customer, 1 if it is seen and fixed at the station in seconds. Engineering answers this one, using the failure analysis of the process and the customer specification.
Arrival. How likely is a defect in the next lot? Score 4 for a new part, a new source or a defect rate above 5,000 per million, 1 for below 100 per million over twelve months. Purchasing answers it from the supplier record.
Detection. Where in your own process would the defect be found? Score 4 if only the customer finds it, 1 if the first station that touches the part catches it. The control plan answers it.
Multiply the three numbers. The result runs from 1 to 64.
From score to class
| Part | Effect | Arrival | Detection | Points |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Valve spool, ground | 4 | 2 | 4 | 32 |
| Sealing kit | 4 | 3 | 3 | 36 |
| Cast manifold body | 3 | 2 | 2 | 12 |
| Pressure sensor | 4 | 1 | 3 | 12 |
| Socket screw M8 | 1 | 2 | 1 | 2 |
| Label set | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 |
Class A starts at 28 points, class B runs from 9 to 27, class C is 8 and below. The thresholds are a starting point, not a law. Two rules keep the result honest: a part moves up by decision at any time, and it moves down only with twelve months of records behind it.
In the example plant the 480 part numbers fell into 58 critical, 142 important and 280 standard parts. Class C carried 55 percent of all receipts. That is where the inspection hours had been sitting, and it is where they were not needed.
What each class gets
Class A gets a full plan: named characteristics from the drawing, a sample of fifty per lot, an acceptance number of zero. The spool went from 22 minutes to 36, because the attention it always deserved was finally available.
Class B gets a shorter plan, a sample of thirty-two, and the chance to earn reduced inspection later.
Class C gets a dock check: identity, quantity, documents, condition and the lot number, four minutes at the receiving counter, then straight to stock. Two spot audits a week keep the class honest.
The result after twelve months: 45 of 120 receipts inspected per week instead of 90, 864 inspection hours instead of 1,584, and supplier defects in assembly down from 38 to 14 a year. Fewer checks, better coverage, because the checks moved to where a defect would do damage.
The class list is not finished work. Review a part when the part, the process or the supplier changes. A class list two years old describes a plant that no longer exists.