Skip to content
Operational Risk Management | Part 2 of 8

Collecting Risks: Four Sources and Eight Areas

A workshop, a plant walk, three years of your own data and the findings from outside. How 38 raw entries become a register of 24 risks.

A register built from a published list of risks reads well and misses the plant. The risks that will cost you money are the ones your own people have already seen, usually twice. Collecting them takes two weeks and four sources.

The workshop

Two hours with maintenance, production, logistics, purchasing, quality, IT and facility, in one room. The question is not what could happen in theory. The question is what went wrong in the last three years and what almost went wrong.

Near misses carry the same information as events and cost nothing to collect. The compressor that tripped on a Friday evening and was back before Monday has the same cause as the one that will trip during the autumn peak.

Nothing is rated in this session. The moment numbers appear, the entries that embarrass someone stop being named.

The plant walk

Six areas, one hour each, with a camera and three questions. What here has no second route: machine, tool, test bench, supply, system, person? What would water, fire or a power cut do in this area, and what is standing on the floor? What takes longest to replace, and where is the second copy of it?

In the example plant, a site for conveyor components, eleven of the 38 raw entries came from the walk. Nobody had named the drying oven under the wooden roof section in the workshop. Everybody saw it on the walk.

Three years of your own data

Disturbance reports, customer complaints and supplier delivery failures are a risk register that has already been written, in the past tense. The example plant checked 412 disturbance reports, 63 complaints and 9 supplier failures, and looked behind every entry with an effect above two days. That produced seven risks that nobody had named in the workshop.

Findings from outside

Audit findings, insurance surveys, supplier assessments and the loss list of a group name what a plant has stopped seeing. In the example they added four risks and corrected two ratings.

Eight areas, so that nothing is forgotten

Area Look for
Equipment and tools Single machines, special tools, test equipment, parts with long lead times
People Single knowledge holders, shift coverage, peaks, qualification for critical stations
Suppliers and logistics Single sources, tooling at the supplier, financial signals, routes and forwarders
IT and data Outage, attack, backups never restored, drawings, programs, parameters
Energy and utilities Grid, compressed air, cooling water, gas, price above the plan, connected load
Buildings and site Fire, water, roof and floor, access roads, storage areas, neighbors
Products and customers Field actions, a safety relevant characteristic, a large customer, launch dates
External events Weather, flooding, a strike at a partner, theft, new requirements from outside

What comes out

Thirty-eight raw entries, nine duplicates merged, five concerns dropped with a reason, and 24 risks left, each written as cause, event and effect with one named owner. Only sixteen of the 24 came from the workshop itself, which is the argument for the other three sources.

The collection round is repeated once a year, and every project, change, new product and new supplier adds to the register at the moment the change is decided. The rating comes next, and it is a separate session on purpose.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.