A rated register is not yet a decision. For every risk above the threshold, four options are held against each other in writing, and the one that is chosen gets a cost, an owner, a date and a residual rating.
The four options
Avoid means the event can no longer happen: stop the activity, or change the design. Drop the product variant that needs the single source motor. Move the drying oven out of the wooden roof section. On paper this is often the cheapest option and in a meeting it is the hardest to decide.
Reduce lowers the probability, the impact, or both. Most measures live here, and every one of them has to say which of the two numbers moves. A sprinkler over the drying oven lowers both. A buffer of finished housings lowers only the impact and leaves the machine exactly as fragile as it was.
Transfer moves part of the financial effect to someone else: cover, liability and penalty clauses, a supplier who holds stock, a service contract with a response time. It moves money, not the event, and the plant still loses the days. Every case of this kind belongs to the responsible function at your site, with a named owner and a date.
Accept means carrying the risk on purpose, with a name, a level and a review date. In the example plant, a site for conveyor components, six of the 24 risks were accepted in writing, among them the theft of a loaded trailer in the yard. A risk that is accepted by nobody in particular has not been accepted at all.
Cost against effect
The order of work comes from one column: the expected loss removed for every EUR 1,000 of measure cost in the first year.
| Measure | Cost year 1 EUR | Expected loss removed EUR | Removed per EUR 1,000 |
|---|---|---|---|
| External machining partner and a ten day housing buffer | 48,000 | 164,000 | 3,417 |
| Offline backups, restore tests, paper fallback | 29,000 | 85,800 | 2,959 |
| Cross training for the peak, two agency frameworks | 18,000 | 42,500 | 2,361 |
| Second source for the drive motor, ten weeks of cover | 62,000 | 87,200 | 1,406 |
| Sprinkler, separation wall, cameras, trained response team | 145,000 | 53,400 | 368 |
The eight measures of the plan cost EUR 440,000 in the first year, of which EUR 315,000 is spent once and EUR 125,000 returns every year. They remove EUR 530,650 of expected loss, so the register falls from EUR 1,000,000 to EUR 469,350 per year and the red field is empty.
Notice the last line. The fire measure is the worst in the table by the ratio and it was the first one started, because its impact class is 5. The ratio sorts the work. It does not decide which work exists.
Residual risk, same scale
After a measure, the risk is rated again with the same two numbers. MC-200 keeps its probability of 40 percent, because the machine is unchanged, and its impact falls from 18 days and EUR 620,000 to 6 days and EUR 210,000. The score goes from 16 to 12, out of the red field and into the orange one.
Two risks stay orange on purpose. The energy cost risk is handed to purchasing and finance, who own the contracts, and the field action risk to quality and to the responsible legal function. Both keep an owner, a date and a line in the register. Neither is treated with a measure the site team could decide alone.