Skip to content
Operational Risk Management | Part 5 of 8

Supply Chain Risk: Single Sources, Cover and Replacement Time

Five questions that sort 180 suppliers into three groups, and the four measures that actually change the number: second source, cover, tooling and watching the signals.

A supplier is a single point of failure that sends invoices. Most plants know which supplier would hurt them, and few can say how long it would take to replace one or how many weeks of cover they hold. Five questions turn that into a number.

Five criteria, one score

Score each from 1 to 5, add them up, and a supplier scores between 5 and 25.

Sources for the part: three or more qualified sources score 1, a single source with no alternative qualified scores 5. Replacement time: below two weeks scores 1, above twelve weeks, or tooling and approval sitting at the supplier, scores 5. Financial and performance signals: stable figures with delivery and quality on target score 1, falling equity, late payments and falling delivery score 5. Site and route concentration: several sites and separate routes score 1, one site and one route in a region with known events scores 5. Share of spend and of the product: below 2 percent scores 1, above 10 percent or a part in every product you sell scores 5.

Above 15 points the supplier is critical and needs a continuity plan. In the example plant, a site for conveyor components, nine of 180 suppliers scored above 15.

Supplier and part Sources Replacement Score
Drive motors, one qualified source, falling equity 1 10 weeks 22
Electronics assembly, one site in a flood area 1 12 weeks 19
Housing castings, tooling at the supplier 1 20 weeks 18
Coating service, regional, one provider 1 6 weeks 14
Steel tube, two qualified sources 2 3 weeks 10

What actually helps

A second source, qualified and ordered from regularly, is the only measure that removes the single point. It costs qualification, tooling, a higher piece price and audit time, and for the drive motor of the example plant it takes fourteen months. A source that exists on paper and has never shipped a lot is not a second source.

Cover, in your stock or at the supplier, buys the weeks the second source needs. The example plant raised the motor cover to ten weeks for the duration of the ramp. Cover costs carrying cost, space and the risk that the part becomes obsolete, and how a safety stock is sized belongs to inventory management. Here it is one measure among four, with its price next to it.

Tooling and drawings in your own hands turn a twenty week replacement into a six week one for the castings, because a new supplier starts with the tool instead of building one. That is a clause in a contract and a place in a rack, and it is cheap compared with twenty weeks.

Watching the signals buys warning time. The motor supplier of the example plant had been visible in its published figures for two years before anyone rated the risk. A quarterly hour per critical supplier is enough, and the judgment about what the figures mean belongs to purchasing and finance.

What it changed

The motor risk was rated at 8 percent per year with an impact of EUR 1,450,000: 26 production days at EUR 34,000, plus EUR 420,000 of penalties and express freight and EUR 146,000 for an emergency qualification. The second source and the cover cost EUR 62,000 in the first year and cut the impact to EUR 360,000, which removes EUR 87,200 of expected loss per year.

Rating and developing suppliers on quality, delivery and price belongs to supplier management. Here a supplier is looked at only as a source of disruption.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.