Skip to content
Production Planning and Control | Part 1 of 10

Three Planning Levels, Three Owners

Monthly, weekly and daily planning answer different questions. Each needs its own horizon, owner and frozen zone.

A valve block plant with 220 employees has an ERP system, a planner and a full shop floor. Yet on-time delivery is 78 percent, and the supervisors decide every morning what really runs. The plan exists, but nobody plans with it.

Most planning problems start with a mix-up of levels. A monthly volume question is answered in the daily meeting, and a daily sequence question is answered by the ERP run on Sunday night.

Three questions, three levels

Production planning answers three different questions:

  • Rough-cut, monthly: how much of which product family do we make in the next three to eighteen months, and do we have the capacity? Owner: the production manager, together with sales and finance.
  • Master schedule, weekly: which orders run in which week for the next four to twelve weeks? Owner: the planner.
  • Detailed, daily: which order runs next at which machine in the next one to five days? Owner: the supervisor, within rules set by the planner.

Each level has its own data. The monthly level works with families and hours per work center. The weekly level works with orders. The daily level works with the queue in front of each machine.

Frozen, firm, free

A plan that changes every day is not a plan. Divide the horizon into three zones:

  • Frozen, weeks 1 and 2: changes only with a recorded decision of the production manager.
  • Firm, weeks 3 to 6: quantities may shift within a family, capacity is reserved.
  • Free, from week 7: open for new orders and forecasts.

The frozen zone protects the shop floor from constant re-planning. It also forces sales to ask early, because a late request now has a visible cost.

A fixed calendar

Planning works when it happens at the same time every week. In the example plant:

  • the rough-cut capacity check runs in week 3 of every month,
  • the planner loads and levels next week on Thursday,
  • the weekly plan is released to the floor on Friday at 10:00,
  • the daily production meeting runs every morning at 07:30.

A fixed calendar sounds bureaucratic. In practice it ends the stream of “can you just squeeze this in” requests, because everybody knows when decisions are made.

The monthly level is where production meets the business plan. If the company runs a sales and operations planning process, the rough-cut capacity check is production’s contribution to it. Without that check, the volume plan is a wish, and the weekly plan inherits the problem.

Where to start

Write the three levels on one page: question, horizon, rhythm, owner and output. Then ask one simple question in the next daily meeting: which decisions are we making here that belong to another level? The answer usually shows where the plan loses its authority.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every week.