Ask five supervisors where the bottleneck is and you may hear five answers. Assembly complains loudest, test has the oldest equipment, the saw breaks down most often. The bottleneck is none of these by default. It is the work center with the highest load relative to its real capacity.
Find it with data
Calculate utilization per work center for the next weeks: load in hours divided by available hours. In the valve block plant, CNC machining runs at 84 to 102 percent, assembly at 76 to 93 percent, all others below 85 percent.
Then confirm it on the floor. A real bottleneck shows three signs:
- a queue of work in front of it,
- idle time behind it, where the next work center waits for parts,
- overtime decisions that keep landing on it.
Be careful with each sign alone. A queue can also come from bad sequencing upstream, idle time from quality holds. The data and the walk together give the answer.
Why it matters so much
The output of the plant cannot be higher than the output of its bottleneck. In the example, one CNC hour produces about three valve blocks. At a contribution of EUR 85 per block, one lost bottleneck hour costs the plant about EUR 255.
One lost hour at the saw costs nothing. The saw runs at 47 percent and catches up in its idle time. This is the most important asymmetry in production planning, and most plants manage every hour as if it were equal.
Five focusing steps
The theory of constraints gives a simple sequence:
- Identify the constraint with load data and observation.
- Exploit it: it must never wait for material, programs, tools or operators, and it must not process defective blanks.
- Subordinate everything else: release, sequence and staffing follow its schedule.
- Elevate it: add shifts or invest only after the first three steps.
- Repeat: when the bottleneck moves, start again.
Most plants jump to step 4. They buy a sixth machining center while the five they have lose 8 percent of their time to missing blanks, programs and break cover.
Protect it every shift
A short checklist at the start of every shift at the bottleneck does more than a new planning tool:
- next three orders with material at the machine,
- programs released and tools preset,
- operators and break cover named,
- first piece check planned,
- planned maintenance known.
When it moves
Bottlenecks move. A shift in mix toward large blocks raises assembly load faster than CNC load. An extra shift at CNC machining makes assembly the bottleneck at about 93 percent. Recalculate the load every month per family, and check the next constraint before you add capacity to the current one.