Large lots save setups and create waiting. Small lots cut waiting and cost setups. The textbook answers the trade-off with one formula. The shop floor needs a better question: where does a setup actually cost something?
The classic formula
The economic lot size balances setup cost against holding cost:
square root of (2 x annual demand x cost per setup / holding cost per unit and year)
For small valve blocks: annual demand 24,000, a setup of 45 minutes at EUR 120 per machine hour costs EUR 90, holding cost is 20 percent of a value of EUR 70, or EUR 14 per block and year. The result is about 555 blocks, a little more than one week of demand.
The formula is a useful starting point. It assumes, however, that every setup hour costs the same. In a plant with a bottleneck, that is not true.
Three kinds of setups
At a bottleneck above 90 percent load, a setup costs output of the whole plant. In the example, 45 minutes of CNC time are about two valve blocks the plant will never ship. Keep lot sizes there and reduce setup time first.
At a bottleneck below 90 percent load, a setup costs free capacity until it is used up. In week 1, CNC machining has 57 free hours. Ten more setups of 45 minutes cost 7.5 hours and still leave room for disruptions. Smaller lots are affordable in such weeks, not in week 5 at 102 percent.
At a non-bottleneck, a setup costs almost nothing. The saw runs at 47 percent. Saving a setup there saves idle time. Smaller lots at the saw cut waiting in front of CNC machining and shorten lead time.
Transfer batches
A lot does not need to move as one block. 500 small blocks take 750 minutes at the saw. If CNC machining waits for the whole lot, it starts after 750 minutes. If the saw passes batches of 50, CNC can start after 75 minutes. The lot is still one setup, but the waiting between the two steps drops from up to 500 blocks to 50.
Transfer batches are often the cheapest lead time reduction in a plant. They need only a decision and a cart.
Reduce setup time at the bottleneck
Every minute of setup saved at the bottleneck is a minute of output gained or a smaller lot made possible. The usual sequence works here too:
- separate internal from external setup work,
- prepare tools, fixtures and programs before the machine stops,
- standardize clamping and use presetting,
- measure ten setups and use the median as the new standard.
The rule of thumb
Set lot sizes deliberately at the bottleneck, based on its free capacity and the target utilization. Cut lot sizes and use transfer batches everywhere else. And recalculate when the load changes, because a lot size that was right at 84 percent is wrong at 102.