A project reports green for five months and red in the sixth. Nothing changed suddenly. The status was based on feeling, and the feeling was optimistic until it could not be anymore.
Status reports exist to trigger decisions. They need rules, not moods.
Color by rule
- Green: all work packages on track, no risk with a score of 12 or more.
- Amber: a work package behind plan, or a high risk without a working response.
- Red: a work package on the critical path late, or the end date at risk.
The color follows the rule. A red status is not a failure of the project manager. It is a request for a decision, and the report says which decision, from whom, by when.
Measure progress with earned value
Percent complete by feeling is the weakest number in project management. Earned value replaces it with three measures:
- Planned value: budget of the work planned until today.
- Earned value: budget of the work actually done.
- Actual cost: cost booked until today.
In the assembly cell example at week 16: planned value EUR 820,000, earned value EUR 740,000, actual cost EUR 790,000.
The schedule performance index is earned value divided by planned value: 740 / 820 = 0.90. The project has done 10 percent less work than planned. The cost performance index is earned value divided by actual cost: 740 / 790 = 0.94. The work done cost 6 percent more than budgeted.
A simple forecast follows: budget divided by the cost index. EUR 1,710,000 / 0.94 = EUR 1,819,000. The project will use most of its contingency of EUR 140,000 if nothing changes. That is a fact for the steering committee in week 16, not a surprise in week 29.
One door for every change
Scope grows in small steps, each of them reasonable. A second variant, a second language on the operator panel, a vision check for the label position. Together they move the end date by a month.
Every change goes through one door:
- Request on one page: what, why, who asks.
- Impact: weeks, cost, risk, effect on the critical path.
- Decision by the person with the A in the RACI: approved, rejected or deferred.
- Update of plan, budget and baseline, and the team informed.
Deferred is a valid answer. “After start of production” protects the date and keeps the idea.
One page
The weekly status fits on one page: overall color and the reason in one sentence, the next two milestones with plan and forecast, budget and forecast at completion, the risks and changes that moved, and the decisions needed. Everything else belongs in the attachment.