Skip to content
Sales and Operations Planning | Part 8 of 10

Scenarios With Triggers Turn Risks Into Prepared Decisions

Build two or three S&OP scenarios with effect, response and a trigger date, and keep one base plan until the executives switch.

A gap without options is a complaint. A scenario without a trigger is an interesting slide. S&OP needs neither. It needs prepared decisions that the executive review can take in minutes when the signal comes.

One base plan

Scenarios do not replace the plan. Operations works to the base plan until the executive review decides to switch. Otherwise every department picks the scenario it likes, and the company is back to three numbers.

Four steps

  1. Assumption: one clear change, such as more volume, a lost supplier or a large project.
  2. Effect: recalculate load, materials, stock and revenue with the same factors as the base plan.
  3. Response: the options that close the gap, with cost, lead time and owner.
  4. Trigger: the signal and the date at which the executive review switches.

The example

The pump manufacturer prepared three scenarios for the first half of 2027:

  • Base: the plan after the bias correction. May load 105 percent, revenue EUR 37.9 million. Response: pre-build plus two Saturday shifts.
  • Upside: plus 8 percent compact pumps from April. May load 108 percent, revenue EUR 38.5 million. Response: temporary staff from March and a third Saturday. Trigger: order intake for compact pumps above 2,700 units in February.
  • Downside: minus 10 percent process pumps. May load 101 percent, revenue EUR 36.4 million. Response: no Saturday shifts, lower module stock. Trigger: process pump orders below 560 units for two months.

Prepared, not executed

The upside response needs temporary staff trained by March. Calling them in March is too late, hiring them in January is too expensive if the upside never comes. The middle way: pre-qualify people with an agency now, at no cost, and call them only when the trigger fires.

This is the real value of scenarios. They move the slow part of a response forward without paying for it.

Few and different

Two or three scenarios are enough. Each should change one thing that matters and lead to a different response. Ten scenarios that differ by two percent create work and no decisions.

Typical scenario drivers in industrial companies:

  • a large customer project won or lost,
  • a supplier or material shortage,
  • a price change by the company or a competitor,
  • an economic shift in one market,
  • a delay of a product launch.

In the executive review

The pre-S&OP prepares one page per scenario: assumption, effect on load and money, response, cost, owner, trigger and date. The executive review confirms the base plan, approves the preparation for each scenario, and decides who watches each trigger.

When a trigger fires between two cycles, the owner calls a short decision meeting instead of waiting for the next month. The decision is already prepared. That is what makes the response fast.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every week.