The function cost table shows where money sits. It does not show whether the product does too much, too little, or exactly what the customer asked for. That is the job of a second table, and it is the one that stops a value study from turning into a cheapening exercise.
Two columns of language
Customers speak in outcomes: the pump must not leak, it has to fit where the old one sat, service should be quick. Engineers work in characteristics: seal life in hours, installed length in millimeters, seal change time in minutes. The requirements matrix puts the first group in the rows and the second in the columns, and fills the cells with the strength of the link between them.
Each requirement gets a weight from 1 to 5, taken from interviews, specifications, lost quotations and complaints, not from a workshop vote. Each cell holds 3 for a strong link, 2 for medium, 1 for weak and nothing where there is no link. Weight times strength, added per column, gives the score of the characteristic, and the scores produce a ranking.
For the coolant pump of this series, seven requirements and eight characteristics gave a clear order: seal life first with 26 points, overall efficiency second with 24, flow third with 21, seal change time fourth with 20, and sound level last with 6.
Required and actual
The ranking alone changes nothing. Next to it belongs a second table with the required value, the value the product delivers today and a plain verdict.
| Characteristic | Verdict | Required | Today |
|---|---|---|---|
| Seal life | Met, no reserve | 16,000 h or more | 16,000 h |
| Bearing life | Twice the requirement | 20,000 h or more | 40,000 h |
| Installed length | Met, little room | 420 mm or less | 410 mm |
| Seal change time | Not met | 20 min or less | 45 min |
| Salt spray resistance | Three times over | 240 h or more | 720 h |
Three findings come out of this, and each one has a consequence for the idea list.
Where the product delivers far more than anyone asked for, there is money to take back. Bearings for 40,000 hours and a coating that survives 720 hours of salt spray are not quality, they are an estimate made years ago that nobody has revisited. The bearing idea saves EUR 3.50 per unit, the single powder coat EUR 3.20 and still reaches 480 hours.
Where the product is below the requirement, an idea may add cost on purpose. Seal change takes 45 minutes against a required 20, on a function customers rate highly. That is the one idea in the study that makes the pump EUR 0.60 more expensive.
Where a characteristic is met with no reserve, nothing is allowed to touch it. Seal life is exactly at the requirement and ranks first. A cheaper seal from a second source would have saved EUR 4.00 and put the top-ranked characteristic at risk. It was rejected on this page, not in the decision meeting.
The matrix also sets limits for ideas that look unrelated. Installed length is at 410 mm against a maximum of 420. The standard frame motor and the omitted base plate both change the length, so both carry a condition: stay below 420 mm or the idea dies.
Keep the form simple
Larger forms exist, with a roof for correlations between characteristics, competitor columns and target rows. They have their place in product development, and the Quality Tools line covers the wider family of planning matrices. For a value study on a product in production, a plain table with weights, link strengths, scores and a required-versus-actual column answers every question the team has. What matters is that each characteristic carries a unit and a number. A requirement without a unit cannot be tested, and an idea cannot be checked against it.
With the ideas rated and checked, what remains is to turn them into target costs per component and to prove, month by month, that the saving actually arrives.