A value study ends with a decision. The saving arrives six months later, if anyone keeps track of it. The last step of the method is the least exciting and the one that decides whether the previous five were worth the effort.
Book the ideas against the components
Every decided idea belongs to a component. Booking them produces a target cost per component, and every component gets an owner.
| Component | Owner | Today EUR | Target EUR |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pump housing | Design | 40.00 | 37.00 |
| Mechanical seal | Design, service | 20.00 | 20.60 |
| Bearings and bracket | Design, manufacturing | 20.00 | 16.50 |
| Motor with coupling | Purchasing | 60.00 | 53.00 |
| Base plate and fasteners | Design | 10.00 | 4.50 |
| Coating and nameplate | Manufacturing | 10.00 | 6.80 |
The seal is the only row that goes up, on purpose. The total of all ten components is EUR 195.20 against the target of EUR 196.00, which leaves a reserve of EUR 0.80. A study that lands exactly on the target usually has one idea in it that was rated optimistically.
From decision to standard cost
Nothing moves until the change process moves. Each idea becomes a change request with drawing, bill of material and routing changes. The tests named in the rating are run: a salt spray test for the coating, a bearing life calculation, a test run for the shortened cycle, a fit check for the installed length. The change board sets an effective date and decides what happens to the stock of old parts. First units are built, measured and costed. Controlling compares the new standard cost with the baseline signed at the start.
That sequence is where most of the elapsed time goes, and it is also where savings quietly disappear. An idea without a change request is a slide. The Engineering Change and Part Approval line describes the process itself; the value study only has to feed it and follow it.
When a saving counts
Three conditions, all of them: the change is in the bill of material, the routing or the purchase price; the first units with the change have been built; controlling has confirmed the new cost against the baseline. Until all three are true, the number is a plan, and plans do not belong in the same column as results.
The tracker shows both. For the coolant pump, the first ideas took effect in month 2, packaging and fasteners worth EUR 2.20 per unit, and the last in month 9, the shortened test run. Confirmed savings after month 6 were EUR 38,000, the planned total for the first year is EUR 178,300, and from month 9 the run rate is EUR 24,800 per month, EUR 297,600 per year against a one-time cost of EUR 82,000.
One distinction keeps the business case honest. The saving of EUR 24.80 per unit is at full cost and includes EUR 4.96 of overhead absorbed on the direct cost. At direct cost the saving is EUR 19.84 per unit and EUR 238,080 per year. The overhead share becomes cash only when overhead cost actually falls or the freed capacity is sold. Say which number you are using, every time.
The cheapest saving is never needed
The same six steps run faster and cost less on a product that is still being designed. Market price, margin and target cost before the concept. Function list and importance from customer interviews. Concepts compared by function cost instead of by part price. A cost estimate per component at every design review against the target, with quotations replacing estimates before release. Nothing has to be unlearned, no tool has to be rebuilt, no stock has to be scrapped.
What stays after a study is a cost statement, a function list, a requirements matrix and an idea list, one set per product. The next study starts from them, and so does the next design.