Skip to content
Cost and Controlling | Part 9 of 10

Lean Savings in Euros: Cash or Capacity

Rules to translate inventory, floor space, scrap and hours into euros, a business case with payback and net present value, and the line between cash and capacity.

The lean team reports 400 setup hours saved, 400 m² of floor space freed and EUR 800,000 less inventory. Controlling looks at the result and sees almost nothing. Both are right, and the argument that follows damages the next improvement project.

The way out is a set of rules, agreed before the project starts.

Translation rules

Effect Rule Example
Inventory Reduction x holding cost rate (capital 8 % plus storage, handling, obsolescence 12 %) EUR 800,000 less = EUR 160,000 a year, plus EUR 800,000 one-off cash
Floor space m² x cost per m², only if the space is used or released 400 m² x EUR 110 = EUR 44,000, if used
Scrap Parts saved x cost per scrapped part 2,512 x 25.74 = EUR 64,659
Hours Hours x rate, cash only if overtime, temporary staff or hiring is avoided 400 setup hours = EUR 29,380

Lead time shows up in inventory and in delivery performance. Count it there, not a second time.

Cash or capacity

The key distinction: cash effects change payments. Fewer castings bought, less overtime paid, less inventory financed. Capacity effects free resources: machine hours, operator time, floor space. They are worth money only when someone uses them, for more output, fewer shifts or an avoided investment.

State both numbers in every business case. Then nobody is surprised when the freed hours do not appear in the cost report, and the plant can decide how to use them.

A business case

A new fixture and a quick changeover program for the bottleneck machine:

  • Investment: EUR 85,000, fixture 60,000, training and project time 25,000.
  • Setup from 90 to 30 minutes: 400 lots x 1 hour x (37.15 + 36.30) = EUR 29,380 a year.
  • Scrap from 3.0 to 1.5 percent: 2,512 parts x EUR 25.74 = EUR 64,659 a year.
  • Annual effect: EUR 94,039. Payback: 85,000 / 94,039 x 12 = 10.8 months.

About 7 of 10 euros are cash, the scrap saving. The setup hours are capacity until the plant uses them.

Net present value in plain words

A euro next year is worth less than a euro today, because today’s euro could earn interest or pay off debt. Net present value discounts each future year at a rate agreed with controlling, here 8 percent, and subtracts the investment.

Over five years: 94,039 x 3.9927 minus 85,000 = EUR 290,470. Above zero, the improvement earns more than the rate. Payback is easier to explain. Net present value is better for comparing projects of different length, for example a washer that pays back in 64 months but runs for ten years.

Check after six months

Every business case gets a check date. Compare the actual cost lines with the plan: did scrap fall, did overtime fall? Plants that check build credibility, and their next project gets its budget faster.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every week.