Skip to content
Cost and Controlling | Part 8 of 10

What Scrap and One OEE Point Are Worth

The cost of a scrapped part depends on where the defect is found, and the value of one OEE point depends on whether the market takes the extra parts.

Shop floor boards show scrap rates and OEE in percent. Plant reports show cost in euros. The two rarely meet, and so a 1 percent change in OEE feels like a detail while a EUR 6,000 variance feels like a crisis.

Two numbers close the gap.

The cost of a scrapped part

A scrapped part costs the material plus all the work done on it before the defect was found. For the valve housing in this series:

Found at Cost of one defect
Incoming inspection EUR 0, the casting goes back to the supplier
After machining EUR 23.32: casting, machining, operator, setup
After assembly and test EUR 25.74: all conversion done
At the customer EUR 25.74 plus handling, freight and claim, often 5 to 10 times the part

At 3 percent scrap and 160,000 good parts, the plant loses 4,948 parts a year. At EUR 25.74 each that is EUR 127,373. Finding defects earlier lowers the cost per defect. Preventing them removes it.

The value of one OEE point

The bottleneck machine runs 4,800 hours a year. One point of OEE is 48 hours. At a cycle time of 0.16 hours that is 300 more parts.

If the market takes the parts, each contributes EUR 20.74: about EUR 6,200 a year for one point. Ten points are worth EUR 62,000, every year.

If the market does not take more parts, the same point is worth the hours it saves, and only if those hours turn into cash: less overtime, one shift fewer, a planned investment avoided. Otherwise it is capacity, valuable but not a saving.

Productivity in one number

A simple measure for the monthly report is good parts per paid direct labor hour. In January the plant produced 12,700 good parts with 2,010 paid direct hours: 6.3 parts per hour. In March, with the porous castings, it was 6.1. The board shows the cause, the report shows the cost.

Put euros on the board

Three numbers turn a shop floor board into a cost board:

  • Cost of scrap this week, in euros, next to the scrap rate.
  • Value of one OEE point on the bottleneck, as a fixed line on the board.
  • Hours of overtime, next to the reason.

Teams do not need cost reports. They need to know what their numbers are worth. When a team leader can say that the scrap of last week cost EUR 2,900, the discussion about a fixture for EUR 8,000 changes.

A warning

Euro values are a way to compare, not a target in themselves. A team that chases euros may pass defects on to the next process. Keep quality and safety rules first, and use the euros to set priorities among the problems that remain.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every week.