Skip to content
Cost and Controlling | Part 5 of 10

Contribution Margin and Break-Even for Plant Managers

How much each part contributes to fixed costs, how many parts a line needs to cover them, and how to rank products by total contribution.

Manufacturing cost answers the question of what a part costs. Contribution margin answers a more useful one for daily decisions: what does each additional part leave behind to pay for everything else?

From price to contribution

For the valve housing VH-40:

Item EUR per part
Price 42.00
Material including scrapped castings 14.64
Direct labor, operator and assembly 5.32
Variable machine cost, energy and tools 1.30
Variable cost 21.26
Contribution margin 20.74

Each part sold contributes EUR 20.74. First it pays the fixed costs of the line, then it becomes profit.

Break-even

The VH-40 line carries EUR 1.9 million of fixed costs a year, including its share of plant and sales overhead. The break-even volume is 1,900,000 / 20.74 = 91,610 parts.

The plan is 160,000 parts. The margin of safety, the share of volume above break-even, is (160,000 minus 91,610) / 160,000 = 42.7 percent. Volume could drop by more than 40 percent before the line loses money. That is a comfortable position, and a useful number when a customer threatens to move part of the business.

Rank by total contribution

Margin per part alone is misleading. A plant with several products should rank them by total contribution per year:

Product Margin per part Volume Total contribution
VH-40 20.74 160,000 3,318,400
VH-25 14.40 210,000 3,024,000
VH-60 29.10 70,000 2,037,000
VS-90 43.90 22,000 965,800

VS-90 has the highest margin per part and ranks low in total. Losing it would hurt less than losing a fraction of VH-40.

The bottleneck changes the ranking

When a machine is full, the scarce resource is not parts but hours on that machine. The right ranking is then contribution per bottleneck hour. A part that contributes EUR 20 in 0.16 hours brings EUR 125 per hour. A part that contributes EUR 44 in 0.50 hours brings EUR 88. With a full bottleneck, the first one wins.

Fixed or variable labor

The example treats direct labor as variable because the plant adjusts its shift patterns every month. In a plant with fixed crews, labor belongs to the fixed costs, the contribution margin rises and the break-even moves. Neither view is wrong. Decide the rule with controlling and keep it.

What managers do with it

Contribution margin answers whether an extra order is worth it, which product gets capacity first, and how much volume the plant can lose before it gets into trouble. Three questions every plant manager is asked, usually on short notice.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every week.