A customer asks for 5,000 extra parts at EUR 30.00. The manufacturing cost is EUR 28.85, plus overhead and margin. Sales says no, the price is below cost. Is that right?
It depends on which costs change because of the order. That is the difference between fixed and variable costs, and it decides more operational choices than any other concept in cost accounting.
Two kinds of cost
Variable costs move with each part: material, energy while cutting, tool wear, in many plants also direct labor when shift patterns are adjusted monthly.
Fixed costs stay when volume changes in the short term: depreciation, rent, indirect staff, management, most of maintenance.
Many costs are in between. Direct labor is often step fixed: crews change in shifts, not per part. Energy has a base load that stays when nothing runs. Write down how your plant treats each block, agree it with controlling, and use it consistently.
The extra order
In the example the variable cost of the part is EUR 21.26: material including scrapped castings, direct labor, energy and tools. At EUR 30.00 each part contributes EUR 8.74 to the fixed costs, in total EUR 43,700.
If the bottleneck has free capacity in the third shift and the order does not change the prices of other customers, the order improves the result. If the bottleneck is full, the same order pushes out parts that contribute EUR 20.74 each, and it destroys money.
The right cost for each question
| Decision | Right cost |
|---|---|
| Extra order with free capacity | Variable cost |
| Overtime or extra shift | Additional cost only: premiums, extra energy |
| Quote a new product | Full cost, because over time all costs must be covered |
| Make or buy for years | Full cost minus the fixed costs that really disappear |
| Shut down a line | Fixed costs that can be cut, and when |
The make or buy case is the classic trap. A part leaves the plant, but the machine, the floor space and the supervisor stay. The fixed costs are now spread over fewer parts, and every other product looks more expensive.
The overhead spiral
The same mechanism works on a larger scale. Volume drops, fixed costs are spread over fewer parts, product costs rise, sales raises prices, volume drops again.
The defense is simple: show the effect of lower volume separately, as a volume variance, instead of pushing it into the product cost. Then everybody sees that the product did not get more expensive. The plant is less loaded.
Use both views
Full cost is right for pricing and long-term decisions. Variable cost is right for short-term ones. Managers who know both, and know which question they are answering, avoid the most expensive mistakes in operations.