Skip to content
Cost and Controlling | Part 4 of 10

What Does One Part Really Cost?

A cost per part calculation along the routing: material, machining, operator, setup, assembly, scrap and overhead, and which lever matters most.

The sales price of a valve housing is EUR 42.00. What does it cost to make? The answer is not in the ERP system as one number. It is a calculation that follows the routing, and every line of it is something operations influences.

Along the routing

Element Basis EUR per part
Material One casting 14.20
Machining 0.16 h at EUR 37.15 5.94
Operator 0.16 h at EUR 18.15 2.90
Setup 1.5 h at EUR 73.45 per lot of 400 0.28
Assembly and test 4 minutes at EUR 36.30 2.42
Scrap 3.0 % of input 0.80
Plant overhead 20 % of conversion cost 2.31
Manufacturing cost 28.85

Conversion cost is everything between material and finished part: machining, operator, setup, assembly and test, here EUR 11.54. The overhead covers planning, quality, maintenance management and administration.

Scrap is a cost line, not a footnote

At 3 percent scrap, every good part carries EUR 0.80 for the parts that were lost. That is almost three times the setup cost per part. Many calculations hide scrap in an overhead rate or ignore it. Then nobody sees that quality is the larger lever.

Which lever matters most?

Change one input at a time and recalculate:

Lever Change Cost per part Effect
Cycle time 0.16 to 0.14 h 27.49 minus 1.36
Scrap 3.0 to 1.5 % 28.44 minus 0.41
Setup 90 to 30 minutes 28.61 minus 0.24
Casting price 14.20 to 14.90 29.57 plus 0.72

Two lessons come out of the table. First, cycle time on the main machine is worth more than any setup project. Second, a 5 percent higher casting price costs three times what cutting setup time by two thirds saves. Purchasing and operations need to look at the same calculation.

Keep it real

A calculation is only as good as its inputs. Three checks keep it honest:

  • Real routing. If the operators use a different sequence or time than the system, use theirs and correct the system.
  • Real scrap. Use the scrap rate of the last six months, not the planned one.
  • Real lot size. If lots are split in practice, the setup cost per part is higher than calculated.

Recalculate the top ten products once a year and whenever the routing, the machine or the supplier changes. Sales uses the same rates for quotes, so a wrong rate on the shop floor becomes a wrong price at the customer.

From cost to decision

The calculation is not an accounting exercise. It shows in euros where the next improvement should go, and it gives every number on the shop floor board a price.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every week.