Skip to content
Cost and Controlling | Part 3 of 10

The Machine Hour Rate: Running Hours, Not Capacity

How to calculate a machine hour rate from six cost elements and real running hours, and why the hours question decides the result.

Every quote, every make or buy decision and every investment case in a machining plant uses machine hour rates. They are the most used and most misunderstood numbers in the plant.

The idea is simple: all costs of a machine for one year, divided by the hours it really runs.

Six cost elements

A machining center bought for EUR 680,000:

Element Basis EUR per year
Depreciation 680,000 over 8 years 85,000
Capital cost 6 % on half the purchase price 20,400
Floor space 60 m² at EUR 110 per m² 6,600
Energy 22 kW x 4,800 h x EUR 0.20 per kWh 21,120
Maintenance 4 % of the purchase price 27,200
Tools and coolant Booked last year 18,000
Total 178,320

Divided by 4,800 running hours: EUR 37.15 per hour.

The hours question

The same machine divided by 8,760 calendar hours gives EUR 20.36. Every part looks cheap, every quote is too low, and the plant wonders why its margins never show up.

Use the hours the machine is planned to run in the year, here 4,800 hours in three shifts. Write that rule down and apply it to all machines. Then rates can be compared, and a low rate means a cheap process, not a different assumption.

Rules that prevent arguments

  • Economic life, not tax life. A machine written off in tax terms after five years still has costs in year seven.
  • Capital cost on half the price. It reflects the average capital tied up over the life of the machine.
  • Metered energy. Large consumers should carry their own power, not share it by square meters.
  • Yearly review. Running hours, energy prices and maintenance change. Rates should follow.

The labor hour rate

The operator next to the machine has a rate too. Gross salary of EUR 48,000 plus employer social costs, in the example 21 percent, gives EUR 58,080 a year. Divided by 1,600 productive hours, after vacation, sickness, training and meetings: EUR 36.30 per hour.

Productive hours, not paid hours. Paid hours would make labor look about 7 percent cheaper than it is. If one operator runs two machines, each machine hour carries EUR 18.15 of operator cost.

What rates are for

Rates turn time into money. With them, a cycle time reduction of 0.02 hours becomes EUR 1.10 per part, a setup of 1.5 hours becomes EUR 110 per lot, and an hour of downtime on the bottleneck becomes a number everybody understands.

They are only as good as their rules. Spend half a day with the controller agreeing them, and every later discussion becomes shorter.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every week.