Skip to content
Cost and Controlling | Part 6 of 10

Flex the Budget Before You Compare

Why actual costs must be compared with a budget adjusted to actual volume, and how operations builds a budget it can steer.

The machining area spent EUR 447,609 in March. The budget was EUR 434,713. Is the area EUR 12,896 over budget?

Not necessarily. The budget was planned for 13,000 good parts. The area produced 12,600. Comparing the two numbers mixes the effect of volume with the effect of performance, and the discussion that follows goes nowhere.

Flexing in four steps

  1. Plan volume. From the sales and operations plan: 13,000 good parts in March.
  2. Standard cost. Quantities and rates per part from the product calculation.
  3. Flex. Variable costs at actual volume, fixed costs at plan.
  4. Compare. Actual against the flexed budget.
Cost line Flexed budget Actual Variance
Material including scrap 184,464 199,660 15,196
Direct labor 67,032 72,716 5,684
Energy and tools 16,380 16,900 520
Fixed costs 158,333 158,333 0
Total 426,209 447,609 21,400

At actual volume the area should have spent EUR 426,209. It spent EUR 21,400 more. That is the performance question. The lower volume is a separate topic, and it belongs to sales and planning.

Build it from the bottom

A budget that operations can steer is built from volume, routings, rates and headcount, not from last year plus 3 percent:

  • September: volume plan per product family and month.
  • October: hours and headcount from routings, productivity targets and absence.
  • October: wage increases, energy contracts and material prices from HR, purchasing and controlling.
  • November: budgets per cost center, agreed with each owner.
  • December: approval by plant management.

The owner who agreed to the budget can explain the variance later. An owner who received a top-down number cannot.

Write improvements into the budget

Planned savings belong in the budget as separate lines with owners and start months, for example “Scrap VH-40 from 3.0 to 1.5 percent, EUR 64,700 a year, from July.” Then they are visible, and the monthly comparison shows whether they arrive.

Forecast, not only budget

The budget is fixed for the year. The forecast is not. Every quarter, update expected volume, prices and costs for the remaining months. The useful question in the review is not “Are we on budget?” but “Where will we land, and what can we still change?”

The payoff

A flexed budget turns the monthly cost meeting from a defense into an analysis. The next step is to split the remaining EUR 21,400 by cause, and that is the topic of the next part.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every week.