Skip to content
Creativity Techniques | Part 1 of 6

Framing the Question: Object, Search Field and Target Figure

Why most idea sessions fail before they start, and the five parts that turn a topic into a question a group can answer in 90 minutes.

A supervisor books a room, invites eight people and writes “transport damage” on the whiteboard. Ninety minutes later the wall is full, everybody has spoken, and nothing happens. The session did not fail in the room. It failed when the topic was written instead of a question.

A topic is not a question

A topic invites every person to answer something different. One hears a cost problem, one hears a layout problem, one hears a people problem, and all three are right. A question is narrower on purpose, and that is what makes the answers comparable.

Five parts turn a topic into a question.

  • Object. What may be changed. In the worked example of this series: the stator housing, its rack, its route and the handover between two areas.
  • Search field. The border in space and process. Here: everything between the paint line and final assembly, and nothing before or after it.
  • Target figure. One figure, with a baseline and a target value.
  • Limits. What must not change, how much may be spent, how fast a first trial has to be possible.
  • Owner. One named person who decides afterward.

Find the baseline before you ask

The plant moves 22,000 stator housings a year between the two areas. The rework record shows 264 damaged per year, 1.2 percent, at EUR 300 a case in rework, repaint, handling and line stop. That is EUR 79,200 a year, and it is the number the question has to move.

Half an hour in the same record changed the question before it was asked:

Where the damage is Cases per year Share
Corner or edge of the flange 212 80 %
Painted outer surface, scratched 34 13 %
Threads and connector seat 18 7 %

Four of five cases are one geometry. The question stopped being about transport in general and became about corners, which is a search field a group can work on in an afternoon.

The question in one sentence

How do we halve the cost of damaged stator housings between the paint line and final assembly within six months, without a new conveyor, with at most EUR 15,000, and with a first trial running inside four weeks?

The limits are not bureaucracy. Without them a group spends twenty of its ninety minutes on a new overhead conveyor, which is a capital project, not an idea. With them, the conveyor idea is still written down, still kept, and goes on the list for the next investment discussion instead of eating the session.

Three tests before you invite anybody

  • Can one person answer it with one change? If the honest answer is no, it is a program and not a question. Split it.
  • Does a number move when the answer works? If not, nobody will be able to tell whether it worked.
  • Would a good answer surprise you? If you already know the answer, you want a decision, not a search.

The split test is the one most often skipped. Count the figures that would have to move. More than one figure means more than one question, and running two as one produces a list where nothing is comparable.

The owner is part of the question

A question without an owner produces a list that nobody is allowed to decide on. The owner brings the baseline, sets the limits, names the date of the decision before the session starts, and answers every idea afterward, including the ones that were not selected. That last part costs twenty minutes and buys the next session.

Written question, measured baseline, stated limits, named owner, fixed decision date. That is the preparation, it takes about two hours, and it is the difference between a wall of cards and five trials.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.