Open tools find what a group can imagine. Systematic tools cover what it forgot, which is usually the combination nobody thought to put together and the conflict nobody said out loud.
The morphological box
Break the solution into parameters, list the options for each parameter, and combine. The box has no good ideas in it. It has all of them, and its value is that it shows the group what it never considered.
| Parameter | Option A | Option B | Option C | Option D |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Load carrier | Pallet | Steel rack | Stacking box | Trolley |
| Protection at the contact points | Foam cutout | Corner protector | Cardboard divider | Coated surface |
| Fixing | Strap | Clamp | Shaped seat | Lid |
| Route | Marked lane | Separate lane | Fixed time slot | No stacking rule |
| Proof of condition | Handover card | Photo | Shock indicator | Seal |
Five parameters with four options each give 1,024 combinations. Nobody reads 1,024 combinations, and nobody has to. The group described three on purpose and took one forward: steel rack, corner protector, shaped seat, marked lane, handover card.
Three rules keep the box usable. Four to six parameters, because more produces a table nobody reads. Parameters must be independent, so if one option rules out a whole other row, the rows belong together. And pick the three combinations deliberately: the cheapest, the safest and the strangest. The strange one is where the hour is earned.
Name the contradiction
Most problems that have been stuck for years hold a contradiction: the plant wants more of something and less of it at the same time, and every proposal so far has been a compromise between the two. Writing the contradiction down is half the work.
In the worked example of this series it reads: we want more protection material at the housing, and we want less protection material, less handling and less waste. Every previous attempt had been a number in the middle, which is why nothing changed.
| Step | In the example |
|---|---|
| Write both demands in one sentence | More protection at the housing, and less material, handling and waste |
| Ask where each demand is really needed | Protection at four corners, where 212 of 264 cases happen |
| Separate in space | Protect the corners, leave the rest of the surface free |
| Separate in time | Added at the paint line, removed in one movement at the station |
| Move the function into the carrier | The protector belongs to the rack, so nothing is added per piece |
The test of a resolved contradiction is simple: both demands are met without a compromise number in the middle. If the answer is sixty percent of each, the contradiction is still there and the group has only bought itself a quieter argument.
Patterns of known solutions
Good solutions repeat their shape across industries, and five plain patterns are worth one pass each. Read one out loud, leave two minutes of silence, let everybody write what it would mean here, then read the cards and keep what is new. Five patterns take about twenty-five minutes.
- Put the function into the carrier. Protection that is part of the rack cannot be forgotten and costs nothing per piece.
- Use what is already there. The offcuts of the foam sheets were paid for and then thrown away.
- Separate what conflicts, in space or in time. The resolution above is this pattern applied twice.
- Let the shape do the positioning. A seat in the right shape puts the part in one place and holds it there.
- Make the loss visible where it happens. A handover check moves the damage from somewhere to a gate with two names on it.
None of this replaces the open tools. It runs after them, when the easy ideas are on the wall and the group needs something other than effort to find the next one.