Skip to content
Creativity Techniques | Part 3 of 6

Four Tools That Get a Group Past Its First Answer

Ordered collection, the seven change questions, the reverse question and trigger words, with the 68 cards they produced in one 90 minute session.

Open discussion produces the ideas the group already had. That is not a small thing, but it is rarely enough: the answers that were already in the room are the ones that have not solved the problem so far. Four tools, none of which needs preparation, reliably produce the others.

Ordered collection

Everybody writes alone for eight minutes, one idea per card. Then one round: each person reads one card aloud, puts it on the wall, and the next person follows. No discussion, no grouping, only questions of understanding. The round continues until all cards are up.

In the worked example this produced 24 of the 68 ideas, and the three quietest people in the room produced nine of them. That is the whole argument for writing before speaking.

The seven change questions

A fixed list, run on the object, then on the carrier, then on the route. Running it three times feels mechanical and works anyway, because each pass puts a different thing under the question.

Question Asked about the example
Replace: what else could do this job? A shaped seat instead of loose foam.
Combine: what could be done in one step? Protection and rack in one part.
Adapt: where has somebody solved something similar? The way a bicycle frame is shipped.
Enlarge: what if we had much more of it? A protector on every corner of every rack.
Reduce: what if we had much less, or none? No stacking at all, one layer per rack.
Rearrange: what if the order or position changed? Housings loaded last and unloaded first.
Remove: what if this part did not exist? No buffer between paint and assembly.

Thirteen cards came from this list, including the idea with the largest expected effect. Empty fields are not a failure: they show where the object has no room left.

The reverse question

Ask the opposite of the goal: how would we make sure that every housing gets damaged? The answers come fast and cheerfully, because they describe what happens today. Stack three racks high. Put other parts on top. Drive through a lane with cross traffic. Let nobody check anything at the handover.

Turn each answer around and you have an idea with its reason already attached. Eleven cards came from this question in ten minutes, and two of the five ideas that went into a trial were among them.

Trigger words

Use these when the group starts repeating itself, usually after forty minutes. Draw a word that has nothing to do with the question and ask what it suggests. The word is not the idea. The link is, and the link is what makes the idea defensible afterward.

Word The link The idea
Egg carton A shape that holds each piece apart and takes the shock A molded seat in the rack
Bicycle Fragile frames ship with four corner pieces and nothing else Corner protectors from foam offcuts
Letterbox One opening, one direction, nothing can be put on top A rack that cannot be stacked
Scaffolding A frame carries, the surface never touches anything Contact only on the unpainted flange

A close relative is the comparison with another field. Name the function in neutral words, here moving something fragile without touching its surface, then name three fields that solve it daily: a bicycle shop, a laboratory, a parcel service. Ask what the equivalent would be here. The laboratory comparison produced the handover card, because a sample that changes hands gets a signature and a condition note at every gate.

What the spread looks like

Twenty-four cards from ordered collection, thirteen from the change questions, eleven from the reverse question, nine from trigger words, seven from other fields and four from the morphological box. No tool produced more than a third of the cards, and the two tools with the fewest cards produced two of the five selected ideas. That is the argument for running several tools rather than one well.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.