Skip to content
Creativity Techniques | Part 5 of 6

From 68 Cards to 5 Trials: Grouping, Screening and Scoring

The four steps that turn a wall of ideas into a short list somebody will pay for, with weighted criteria and an effort against effect picture.

The value of a session is decided after the session. A wall of cards is not a result, and a group that watches its wall get photographed and filed learns quickly that the exercise is decorative. Four steps, about one hour, one decision.

Step Ideas left What happens
Collected in the session 68 Six tools, 90 minutes, six people writing
After merging duplicates 41 Nine groups. 27 cards said the same thing twice
Inside the search field 29 12 broke a limit or belonged to another question
Above the score threshold 12 Four weighted criteria, 24 of 35 points needed
Selected for a trial 5 Chosen along the effort and effect line

Group before you rate

Move the cards into groups in silence first, and name the groups afterward rather than before. Naming first creates the categories somebody expected and quietly forces every card into them.

Twenty-seven of the 68 cards turned out to be duplicates. That is not waste. A card that four people wrote independently is a card with support, and it is worth noting on the merged idea which of them wrote it.

Screen against the limits

Four questions, asked before anything is scored, because scoring an idea that breaks a stated limit wastes the group’s attention and then disappoints somebody.

  • Is it inside the search field? Six ideas were about the paint process or the customer packaging. Another question, separate list.
  • Does it respect the limits? Six ideas needed a new conveyor, a robot or more than EUR 15,000.
  • Is it one idea or several? Three cards were split into two ideas each.
  • Can we describe the trial in one sentence? If not, the idea goes back for one round of rewriting.

Ideas outside the limits are kept, never deleted. The six that only needed money became the agenda of the next investment discussion, and the six that belonged elsewhere became two new questions on the register.

Score with weights

Four criteria, the same for every idea, each scored from 1 to 5 where 5 is best, each multiplied by a weight. Maximum 35 points, threshold 24.

Criterion What 5 points means Weight
Effect on the target figure Many cases avoided per year 3
Effort Little money, few hours, few people who have to agree 2
Speed A trial can run next week 1
Acceptance The people who do the work asked for it 1

Twelve of the 29 ideas passed. The weights matter more than the scores: giving effect three times the weight of speed is a management decision, and it should be made once, in writing, before anybody sees the list.

Effort against effect

Plot the one-time cost on one axis and the effect per year on the other, then draw a line through each axis. With the lines at EUR 1,500 and EUR 5,000 the 29 ideas fell into four fields:

Field Ideas What to do
Low cost, high effect 4 Start this week. All four were selected
High cost, high effect 3 One page, one budget round. One was selected
Low cost, low effect 15 Do them when somebody is already there
High cost, low effect 7 Say no in writing and give the reason

The picture does the arguing. Nobody has to defend starting with a EUR 1,200 cutting jig instead of a EUR 48,000 rack system when both are on the same chart.

Decide, then answer everybody

The owner decides within one week. Five ideas went into a trial. The other 63 need an answer, and three sentences on the board are enough: these are in trial, these are on the list for the next question, these are outside the limits and here is why. That is the cheapest part of the method, the one most often skipped, and the reason the second session produces as many cards as the first.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.