Skip to content
Creativity Techniques | Part 2 of 6

Rules and Roles: Why Most Idea Sessions Bring Nothing

The five ways an idea session fails, the five rules that prevent them, and a 90 minute agenda with a result after every block.

Ask anybody in a plant what they think of idea sessions and you get a polite answer and a long pause. The pattern of failure is remarkably stable, and none of the five causes has anything to do with how creative the people are.

Five ways to fail

What happened What it looks like
No question The topic was how can we get better. Six people answered six different questions.
Judged while collecting The third idea was answered with we tried that in 2019. Nobody offered a tenth.
The loudest voice Two people spoke for 40 minutes. Four people had an idea and kept it.
No owner Nobody in the room could decide, so the list went into a folder.
No selection step Forty ideas, no criteria, no decision. The group concluded that ideas do not help.

All five are organizational. All five are preventable with rules that cost nothing.

Five rules

  1. Silent and written first. Every person writes alone for eight minutes, one idea per card. The first spoken idea sets the frame for everybody else, so nobody speaks until everybody has written.
  2. Nothing is judged while ideas are collected. No history, no cost, no but. The facilitator stops a judging remark in one sentence and moves on.
  3. Quantity before quality. The tenth idea is usually better than the second, because the first few are the ones the group already had.
  4. Build on other cards. Reading out loud exists so that ideas can be combined, and the facilitator says so before the round starts.
  5. One question only. A card that belongs to a different question goes on a second list, visibly, and becomes a later session.

Who is in the room

Seven people in the worked example of this series, six of them writing.

  • Owner of the question, who brings question, baseline and limits and decides afterward.
  • Facilitator, who keeps the time and the rules and contributes no ideas. Whoever defends an idea cannot also protect the group from judgment.
  • Three people who do the work: the paint line operator, the final assembly operator who opens the rack, the tow tractor driver who knows the joints in the floor.
  • One technical head from maintenance or engineering, there to say what is possible rather than what is impossible.
  • A writer, who puts every card into the file on the same day with the tool it came from.

Below five the group stays inside one head. Above eight the quiet half stops writing.

Ninety minutes

Minutes What happens Result
0 to 10 The owner reads question, baseline and limits. Questions about the question only. Everybody answers the same question
10 to 18 Silent writing, one idea per card. First cards
18 to 33 One round, every card read out and put on the wall. All cards visible
33 to 48 The seven change questions on object, carrier and route. Second wave of cards
48 to 58 Reverse question, then every answer turned around. Cards from the weak points
58 to 68 Trigger words and comparisons with other fields. Cards from outside the plant
68 to 80 Grouping. Cards that say the same thing go on top of each other. Nine groups
80 to 90 Next step, date of the decision, who writes the list. Date and owner

Each block has a tool and a result. That is what keeps a session from becoming a discussion, and why the agenda is written in minutes.

What the facilitator actually does

Three things. Keep the clock, so the group reaches the grouping block with energy left. Keep the rules, which in practice means stopping the first but of the day quickly and lightly, because everybody is watching to see whether the rule is real. And keep the question visible, so a card belonging elsewhere can be moved without an argument.

A session above 120 minutes loses the quiet half of the room. If the question needs more, it is more than one question.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.