Skip to content
Equipment Specification and Acceptance | Part 3 of 6

Comparing Equipment Quotations: Technical Score and Life Cycle Cost

How to check quotations against must requirements, score them technically and compare the cost over the years of use.

When the quotations arrive, the lowest price has a strong voice. A structured comparison gives the other arguments a number as well.

The same package for everyone

For the assembly cell AC7, five suppliers received the same inquiry package on the same day: the specification with its 64 requirements as a file, drawings and sample parts, the layout, a quotation form with a fixed price breakdown, and the dates. Questions were collected until a fixed day, and every answer went to all suppliers. Four of them quoted.

Each supplier had to mark every requirement: fulfilled, fulfilled with a deviation, or not fulfilled.

Step 1: the must requirements

A quotation that fails a must requirement is clarified once and then excluded. Supplier D offered the lowest price, EUR 1,020,000, with a cycle time of 28 seconds and no proof of torque capability. It failed two of 42 must requirements and left the comparison. Suppliers A, B and C fulfilled all 42.

Step 2: the technical score

Criteria and weights are fixed before the quotations are opened. Otherwise the favorite writes the criteria. The team of AC7 agreed six criteria with weights adding up to 100: want requirements fulfilled 24, process concept and robustness 24, maintainability and access 16, controls and standard components 12, references and project team 12, service and spare parts supply 12.

Each criterion is scored from 0 to 4, first by each person alone, then together. Points are the weight times the score, divided by 4. Every score gets one sentence of evidence: a page of the quotation, an answer, an observation at a reference visit.

The result: supplier A 56 points, supplier B 81, supplier C 79.

Step 3: the cost over the years of use

The price is paid once. Operators, maintenance and energy are paid every year. The team added the cost over eight years, without discounting.

EUR A B C
Purchase price 1,090,000 1,180,000 1,265,000
One-time cost with installation, training, spare parts 1,215,000 1,275,000 1,360,000
Running cost per year 371,000 256,000 258,000
Life cycle cost over 8 years 4,183,000 3,323,000 3,424,000

Supplier A is EUR 90,000 cheaper than supplier B at the order and EUR 860,000 more expensive over eight years. The reason is one line in the quotation: the concept of A needs three operators per shift, the concepts of B and C need two. At EUR 52,000 per operator and year in two shifts, that is EUR 104,000 every year.

Step 4: the decision

The commercial score sets the lowest life cycle cost to 100 and the others in proportion: A 79.4, B 100.0, C 97.1. With the technical and the commercial score weighted 50 percent each, the overall result is:

  • Supplier A: 67.7
  • Supplier B: 90.5
  • Supplier C: 88.0

Supplier B received the order for EUR 1,180,000, inside the budget of EUR 1,200,000. Over 3,456,000 units in eight years, the cell costs EUR 0.96 per unit.

Test the result

B and C are close. Before the decision, the team changed the weights and the years of use to see whether the winner would change. It did not.

Checkpoints for the order

The order turns the specification into an obligation. Before signing, the project lead checks a short list. Are the specification, the clarifications and the quotation named with version and date? Are the acceptance stages, the criteria and the classes of open points part of the order? Is each payment linked to a passed stage and not to a calendar date? Is there a written change procedure?

For AC7, 30 percent were due at the order, 30 percent after the factory acceptance test, 30 percent after the site acceptance test and 10 percent after final acceptance. This is an example, not a recommendation. Terms, liability and warranty must be reviewed by purchasing and legal counsel.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every two weeks.