The factory acceptance test, in short FAT, proves at the supplier that the equipment works before it is taken apart and shipped. Problems found here are solved by the people who built the machine, in their own workshop, with their own tools. The same problem found in your plant costs production days.
A FAT is not a demonstration. In a demonstration the supplier shows what works. In a test the buyer checks what was specified.
Four conditions
A protocol agreed in advance. For the assembly cell AC7, the protocol was the list of the 31 requirements with the stage FAT, each with its acceptance criterion and sample size. It was agreed four weeks before the test.
Parts from the real process. The plant sent 600 sets of components in all three variants, plus limit samples at both ends of the tolerance and prepared fault parts: a housing without thread, a wrong spool, a missing screw. A machine tested only with selected parts has not been tested.
The plant’s own team. The project lead, two operators, two maintenance technicians and the quality engineer. The operators ran the cell, and the technicians exchanged wear parts with a stopwatch running.
A pre-test by the supplier. The supplier ran the protocol alone one week earlier and sent the record.
Two days in week 26
The test of AC7 took two days. Functions and fault handling came first, then a run of 300 units for the cycle time, then the capability runs of 50 units.
| Test point | Criterion | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Cycle time | At most 25.0 s over 300 units | 26.4 s |
| Screw torque capability | Index of at least 1.67 | 1.48 |
| Safety function records | Record for each of 9 functions | 7 of 9 |
| Changeover between variants | At most 10 minutes | 14 minutes |
Twenty-seven of 31 test points passed, among them the press-fit force with a capability index of 1.92 and the leak test with a measurement variation of 8.4 percent of the tolerance. Four failed. In addition the team noted 19 observations.
Three classes of open points
Every failed test point and every observation goes into one list with a class.
- Class A blocks the next step. No shipment until it is closed.
- Class B must be closed before final acceptance.
- Class C may be closed after final acceptance, with a date in the certificate.
The classes are defined in the specification, not negotiated at the machine. After the FAT of AC7 the list had 23 points: 3 of class A, 12 of class B and 8 of class C. The cycle time, the torque capability and the missing safety records were class A. The changeover time was class B, because it could be improved on site.
No shipment on class A
The pressure to ship is high at this moment. Shipping with open class A points moves the problem to the place where it is hardest to solve.
AC7 stayed. The supplier changed the handling sequence at the screw station and the control of the screwdriver. In a re-test of one day in week 27, the cycle time was 24.6 seconds, the torque capability 1.81, and all nine safety records were complete. The shipment release was signed by both sides, and delivery moved from week 28 to week 29.
One week of delay at the supplier is cheap. The previous cell of the plant was shipped on time and reached its output 14 weeks late.
What the release contains
The shipment release is one page: the number of test points passed and failed, the open points by class with owner and date, the statement that no class A point is open, and two signatures. In the order of AC7, the second payment of 30 percent was linked to this page, not to a calendar date.
After the release, the cell is taken apart and shipped. On site, the test starts again, with different questions.