Maintenance has no shortage of numbers. It has a shortage of numbers with clear definitions that lead to decisions. Seven figures are enough to steer a maintenance organization, if they are defined the same way every month.
Leading figures: does the system work?
| Key figure | Formula | Start | Month 12 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Planned share | Hours on planned jobs / all maintenance hours | 38 % | 65 % |
| Schedule compliance | Done scheduled hours / scheduled hours | 64 % | 86 % |
| PM compliance | Preventive tasks done on time / tasks due | 71 % | 92 % |
| Ready backlog | Ready hours / available hours per week | 5.8 weeks | 3.1 weeks |
Leading figures move first. When the planned share rises, failures fall a few months later.
Lagging figures: does it pay?
| Key figure | Formula | Start | Month 12 |
|---|---|---|---|
| MTBF of the bottleneck | (Operating time - repair time) / failures | 156 h | 240 h |
| MTTR of the bottleneck | Repair time / failures | 4.0 h | 3.1 h |
| Cost per replacement asset value | Maintenance cost / replacement value of all assets | 4.2 % | 3.8 % |
A worked example for MTBF and MTTR
The bottleneck machining center in the last quarter: 1,440 operating hours, 9 failures, 36 hours of repair.
- MTBF = (1,440 - 36) / 9 = 156 hours.
- MTTR = 36 / 9 = 4.0 hours.
- Availability from failures = 156 / (156 + 4) = 97.5 percent.
MTBF responds to strategy: better preventive and condition based tasks, root cause analysis, redesign. MTTR responds to preparation: spare parts on the shelf, job plans, skills on every shift.
Both are only as good as the feedback on the work orders. If emergencies are not recorded or repair hours are guessed, the figures show the quality of the paperwork rather than the equipment.
Cost per replacement asset value
The example plant spends EUR 2.6 million per year on maintenance, against a replacement asset value of EUR 62 million: 4.2 percent. The figure makes plants and years comparable, but it needs context. Falling cost with falling availability is not a success. Track it together with output and the planned share.
One page per month
Put the seven figures on one page with target, trend and an owner, and discuss it monthly with production and engineering. A figure without an owner and an action is decoration.
Two rules keep the page honest:
- Definitions do not change during the year. If a definition must change, recalculate the history.
- Every red figure gets one action with an owner and a date, recorded in the meeting.
What not to measure
Avoid figures that reward the wrong behavior. “Number of closed work orders” rewards splitting jobs. “Maintenance cost” alone rewards postponing necessary work. “Response time” alone rewards fast arrival and slow repair.
The last part of this series shows how to use the data to attack the assets that cause most of the trouble.