Skip to content
Lean and Green | Part 9 of 10

Rank Measures by Payback and Cost per Metric Ton

Put every energy and resource measure on the same card with kWh, EUR, CO2e and investment, then rank and verify with the meter.

After the first walks a plant usually has a long list of ideas. The loudest voice tends to win, or the most visible project, often new lighting. A simple card for every measure lets the numbers decide instead.

One card per measure

Every measure gets the same fields:

  • savings per year in kWh,
  • savings in EUR at the same prices for all measures,
  • savings in kg CO2e with the same factors,
  • investment,
  • simple payback: investment divided by savings per year,
  • owner and date.

Eight measures in the example

Measure EUR per year CO2e Payback
Pressure from 7.5 to 6.5 bar 10,080 19.2 t 0.2 years
Scrap on line 3 129,600 23.5 t 0.2 years
Shutdown routine 90,240 171.5 t 0.3 years
Leak program 28,800 54.7 t 0.3 years
Washer at 60 degrees Celsius 10,800 36.2 t 0.7 years
Variable speed drives 18,000 34.2 t 1.2 years
Heat recovery 18,000 60.3 t 2.5 years
LED in hall 2 24,000 45.6 t 2.9 years

Together they save EUR 329,520 and 445 t CO2e per year, 23 percent of the plant emissions, for EUR 210,000 of investment. The package pays back in under eight months.

Cost per metric ton of CO2e

Payback ranks by money. Cost per metric ton ranks by climate effect per euro: the investment spread over its life, minus the annual saving, divided by the metric tons avoided.

A negative value means the measure saves money for every metric ton avoided. In the example all eight are negative. Even LED lighting, with the longest payback, saves about EUR 420 per metric ton over 15 years.

Use both rankings. Payback tells you what to do first. Cost per metric ton tells you which investments still make sense when the quick wins are done.

Quick wins fund the rest

Start with the measures that pay back within a year: routines, settings, leaks. They need little money and show results within weeks. Their savings then fund the measures with longer payback, such as heat recovery.

Verify with the meter

A saving counts when the meter shows it. Read the same meter four weeks before and four weeks after, scale the period before to the output of the period after, and correct for the season where heating is involved.

In the example the leak program was planned at 144 MWh per year. The compressor meter showed about 169 MWh. The card records the measured value next to the plan. Over time, these verified numbers make the next estimates far more credible.

Newsletter

One Lean idea.
Every week.